Original hotel
English
Burgh Island Hotel vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Effectively tied overall
These hotels are effectively tied overall. Use the strengths, trade-offs, and key differences below to choose what matters most.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Hotels (3 selected)
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Bigbury on Sea, GB
★ 4-star9/101 reviews
0.32 km (0.20 mi) from original
Our pick
24 Burgh Island Causeway
Bigbury on Sea, GB
★ 4-star8/104 reviews
0.32 km (0.20 mi) from original
Key differences
Burgh Island Hotel amenity advantages
Non-smoking roomsRestaurantRoom serviceSpa/wellness centerSauna
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Burgh Island Hotel
9.2/1013 Burgh Island Causeway
9/1024 Burgh Island Causeway
8/10Rooms
Burgh Island Hotel
9.6Highly positive: beautiful Art Deco/original furnishings, large bathrooms and balcony rooms with great views noted by multiple guests.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackCleanliness
Burgh Island Hotel
9.2No cleanliness issues mentioned in reviews — standard quality for this hotel tier.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackLocation
Burgh Island Hotel
9.8Very strong: spectacular scenery, causeway and beach views, balcony vistas and an iconic, well-located building repeatedly praised.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackService
Burgh Island Hotel
8.8Mixed: several reviews praise exceptionally warm, attentive and empowered staff (GM and team singled out), but there are notable service failures (poor afternoon tea service, a staff lie, and a management/booking handling disappointment) that lower the score slightly.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackSleep & Noise
Burgh Island Hotel
—13 Burgh Island Causeway
—24 Burgh Island Causeway
—Food & Breakfast
Burgh Island Hotel
8.6Mixed: some dining (Pilchard Inn fish & chips, scones) praised, but afternoon tea service problems, late/cold tea and average sandwiches/cakes were reported.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackAmenities & Facilities
Burgh Island Hotel
9.0Good: Mermaid pool, unique tractor rides and period features are highlights, but a lack of a shop for small items (e.g., shampoo) was mentioned.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackValue
Burgh Island Hotel
9.2Not explicitly discussed in reviews — standard quality for this hotel tier.
13 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedback24 Burgh Island Causeway
Not enough guest feedbackLandmarks
Burgh Island Hotel
Fisherman's Gardens13 Burgh Island Causeway
Warren Point24 Burgh Island Causeway
Warren Point