Original hotel
English
Poinciana House vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Effectively tied overall
These hotels are effectively tied overall. Use the strengths, trade-offs, and key differences below to choose what matters most.
Citadel RosehallPOINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Hotels (4 selected)
POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Montego Bay, JM
★ 0-star9.2/106 reviews
2.4 km (1.5 mi) from original
Our pick
Marriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Montego Bay, JM
★ 0-star7.8/108 reviews
4.4 km (2.7 mi) from original
Key differences
Citadel Rosehall amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom service
Marriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay amenity advantages
Swimming pool
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 3.5 km.
Citadel Rosehall: 0.86 km (0.54 mi)
Marriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay: 4.4 km (2.7 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Poinciana House
9.7/10Citadel Rosehall
5/10POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
9.2/10Marriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
7.8/10Rooms
Poinciana House
9.8Super comfy bed and spacious rooms.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackCleanliness
Poinciana House
9.8Spotless rooms as mentioned in the reviews.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackLocation
Poinciana House
10.0Perfect location — close to attractions.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackService
Poinciana House
10.0Friendly staff and a welcoming owner who went above and beyond.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackSleep & Noise
Poinciana House
—Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
—Marriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
—Food & Breakfast
Poinciana House
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackAmenities & Facilities
Poinciana House
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackValue
Poinciana House
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Citadel Rosehall
—POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Not enough guest feedbackMarriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Not enough guest feedbackLandmarks
Poinciana House
Greenwood Great House (1780)Citadel Rosehall
Greenwood Great House (1780)POINCIANA APARTMENT ONE 257 POINCIANA DRIVE GREEN WOOD MONTEGO BAY JAMAICA
Greenwood Great House (1780)Marriott SeaCastles F36, Montego Bay
Rose Hall Great House (1770)