Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

Anthering, AT

★ 4-star8.9/10634 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

8.8

Many guests praise large, modern and comfortable rooms and beds; a few noted compact deluxe-room sizes and mattresses that were too soft.

Cleanliness

9.2

Guests repeatedly mention rooms are very clean and well maintained.

Location

9.2

Frequently praised for a convenient location near Salzburg, peaceful village setting and good access for excursions; parking available but a car is recommended.

Close alternatives

No close alternative was identified for this preference.

Hotels (3 selected)

Original hotel

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

Anthering, AT

★ 4-star9.1/1066 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

Anthering, AT

★ 4-star8.9/10634 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View hotel

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

Anthering, AT

★ 3-star8.7/10505 reviews

2.4 km (1.5 mi) from original

View hotel

Trade-offs

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Service9.9

Amenities & Facilities8.9

Value9.4

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Amenities & Facilities8.7

Key differences

Cleanliness

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser9.2

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick8.2

Service

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede9.9

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick9.1

Food & Breakfast

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser9.4

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede7.9

Amenities & Facilities

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede8.9

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser7.8

Value

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede9.4

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser8.6

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede amenity advantages

Room serviceBusiness centerConcierge serviceLaundryWheelchair accessible

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser amenity advantages

Fitness centerPets allowedBreakfast in the room

Detailed comparison

Category	Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede	Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser	Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick
Guest score	9.1/10	8.9/10	8.7/10
Rooms	8.9 Rooms were clean and spacious, but some furnishings seemed a bit outdated.	8.8 Many guests praise large, modern and comfortable rooms and beds; a few noted compact deluxe-room sizes and mattresses that were too soft.	8.6 Positive feedback on spacious and well-equipped rooms.
Cleanliness	8.9 Guests appreciated the clean rooms, but some noted aging facilities.	9.2 Guests repeatedly mention rooms are very clean and well maintained.	8.2 Mixed sentiments with mentions of maintenance issues and cleanliness in some reviews.
Location	9.4 Surrounded by nature and quiet, providing a peaceful experience, though somewhat isolated.	9.2 Frequently praised for a convenient location near Salzburg, peaceful village setting and good access for excursions; parking available but a car is recommended.	9.2 Consistently praised for quiet and convenient positioning near Salzburg.
Service	9.9 The owner was accommodating and friendly throughout the stay.	9.3 Multiple reports of very friendly, attentive staff and helpful service, though one guest reported an unfriendly interaction with the owner at arrival.	9.1 Multiple reviews highlight friendly and helpful staff.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	7.9 Breakfast had limited variety and some guests expected more from the dinner options.	9.4 Excellent, varied breakfast repeatedly praised; restaurant and outdoor dining area also receive strong positive mentions.	8.7 Multiple reviews commend the quality and variety of breakfast.
Amenities & Facilities	8.9 Limited dining options were available, but the sauna and peaceful atmosphere were appreciated.	7.8 Nice guest garden and free access to a nearby outdoor pool are highlights; several guests noted lack of air conditioning in some rooms and limited bike-storage options.	8.7 General satisfaction, though some rooms lack certain conveniences like kettles.
Value	9.4 Overall good value considering the unique location and setting.	8.6 Overall positive value thanks to strong breakfast and service, but extra charges (e.g., for dogs) and occasional room-size/mattress issues temper perceived value.	8.6 Favorable reviews suggest good value considering the location and service.
Distance from original	Original hotel	2.1 km (1.3 mi)	2.4 km (1.5 mi)
Landmarks	Denkmal Gabrielen-Aussicht	Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt	Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt
Best suited for	Families	Comfort-focused travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.1/10

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

8.9/10

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.7/10

Rooms

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

8.9

Rooms were clean and spacious, but some furnishings seemed a bit outdated.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

8.8

Many guests praise large, modern and comfortable rooms and beds; a few noted compact deluxe-room sizes and mattresses that were too soft.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.6

Positive feedback on spacious and well-equipped rooms.

Cleanliness

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

8.9

Guests appreciated the clean rooms, but some noted aging facilities.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.2

Guests repeatedly mention rooms are very clean and well maintained.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.2

Mixed sentiments with mentions of maintenance issues and cleanliness in some reviews.

Location

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.4

Surrounded by nature and quiet, providing a peaceful experience, though somewhat isolated.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.2

Frequently praised for a convenient location near Salzburg, peaceful village setting and good access for excursions; parking available but a car is recommended.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

9.2

Consistently praised for quiet and convenient positioning near Salzburg.

Service

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.9

The owner was accommodating and friendly throughout the stay.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.3

Multiple reports of very friendly, attentive staff and helpful service, though one guest reported an unfriendly interaction with the owner at arrival.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

9.1

Multiple reviews highlight friendly and helpful staff.

Sleep & Noise

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

—

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

—

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

—

Food & Breakfast

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

7.9

Breakfast had limited variety and some guests expected more from the dinner options.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.4

Excellent, varied breakfast repeatedly praised; restaurant and outdoor dining area also receive strong positive mentions.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.7

Multiple reviews commend the quality and variety of breakfast.

Amenities & Facilities

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

8.9

Limited dining options were available, but the sauna and peaceful atmosphere were appreciated.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

7.8

Nice guest garden and free access to a nearby outdoor pool are highlights; several guests noted lack of air conditioning in some rooms and limited bike-storage options.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.7

General satisfaction, though some rooms lack certain conveniences like kettles.

Value

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.4

Overall good value considering the unique location and setting.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

8.6

Overall positive value thanks to strong breakfast and service, but extra charges (e.g., for dogs) and occasional room-size/mattress issues temper perceived value.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.6

Favorable reviews suggest good value considering the location and service.

Landmarks

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

Denkmal Gabrielen-Aussicht

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt

Hotels (3 selected)

Original hotel

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

Anthering, AT

★ 4-star9.1/1066 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

Anthering, AT

★ 4-star8.9/10634 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View hotel

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

Anthering, AT

★ 3-star8.7/10505 reviews

2.4 km (1.5 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede	Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser	Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick
Guest score	9.1/10	8.9/10	8.7/10
Rooms	8.9 Rooms were clean and spacious, but some furnishings seemed a bit outdated.	8.8 Many guests praise large, modern and comfortable rooms and beds; a few noted compact deluxe-room sizes and mattresses that were too soft.	8.6 Positive feedback on spacious and well-equipped rooms.
Cleanliness	8.9 Guests appreciated the clean rooms, but some noted aging facilities.	9.2 Guests repeatedly mention rooms are very clean and well maintained.	8.2 Mixed sentiments with mentions of maintenance issues and cleanliness in some reviews.
Location	9.4 Surrounded by nature and quiet, providing a peaceful experience, though somewhat isolated.	9.2 Frequently praised for a convenient location near Salzburg, peaceful village setting and good access for excursions; parking available but a car is recommended.	9.2 Consistently praised for quiet and convenient positioning near Salzburg.
Service	9.9 The owner was accommodating and friendly throughout the stay.	9.3 Multiple reports of very friendly, attentive staff and helpful service, though one guest reported an unfriendly interaction with the owner at arrival.	9.1 Multiple reviews highlight friendly and helpful staff.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	7.9 Breakfast had limited variety and some guests expected more from the dinner options.	9.4 Excellent, varied breakfast repeatedly praised; restaurant and outdoor dining area also receive strong positive mentions.	8.7 Multiple reviews commend the quality and variety of breakfast.
Amenities & Facilities	8.9 Limited dining options were available, but the sauna and peaceful atmosphere were appreciated.	7.8 Nice guest garden and free access to a nearby outdoor pool are highlights; several guests noted lack of air conditioning in some rooms and limited bike-storage options.	8.7 General satisfaction, though some rooms lack certain conveniences like kettles.
Value	9.4 Overall good value considering the unique location and setting.	8.6 Overall positive value thanks to strong breakfast and service, but extra charges (e.g., for dogs) and occasional room-size/mattress issues temper perceived value.	8.6 Favorable reviews suggest good value considering the location and service.
Distance from original	Original hotel	2.1 km (1.3 mi)	2.4 km (1.5 mi)
Landmarks	Denkmal Gabrielen-Aussicht	Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt	Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt
Best suited for	Families	Comfort-focused travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.1/10

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

8.9/10

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.7/10

Rooms

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

8.9

Rooms were clean and spacious, but some furnishings seemed a bit outdated.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

8.8

Many guests praise large, modern and comfortable rooms and beds; a few noted compact deluxe-room sizes and mattresses that were too soft.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.6

Positive feedback on spacious and well-equipped rooms.

Cleanliness

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

8.9

Guests appreciated the clean rooms, but some noted aging facilities.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.2

Guests repeatedly mention rooms are very clean and well maintained.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.2

Mixed sentiments with mentions of maintenance issues and cleanliness in some reviews.

Location

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.4

Surrounded by nature and quiet, providing a peaceful experience, though somewhat isolated.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.2

Frequently praised for a convenient location near Salzburg, peaceful village setting and good access for excursions; parking available but a car is recommended.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

9.2

Consistently praised for quiet and convenient positioning near Salzburg.

Service

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.9

The owner was accommodating and friendly throughout the stay.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.3

Multiple reports of very friendly, attentive staff and helpful service, though one guest reported an unfriendly interaction with the owner at arrival.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

9.1

Multiple reviews highlight friendly and helpful staff.

Sleep & Noise

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

—

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

—

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

—

Food & Breakfast

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

7.9

Breakfast had limited variety and some guests expected more from the dinner options.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

9.4

Excellent, varied breakfast repeatedly praised; restaurant and outdoor dining area also receive strong positive mentions.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.7

Multiple reviews commend the quality and variety of breakfast.

Amenities & Facilities

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

8.9

Limited dining options were available, but the sauna and peaceful atmosphere were appreciated.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

7.8

Nice guest garden and free access to a nearby outdoor pool are highlights; several guests noted lack of air conditioning in some rooms and limited bike-storage options.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.7

General satisfaction, though some rooms lack certain conveniences like kettles.

Value

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

9.4

Overall good value considering the unique location and setting.

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

8.6

Overall positive value thanks to strong breakfast and service, but extra charges (e.g., for dogs) and occasional room-size/mattress issues temper perceived value.

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

8.6

Favorable reviews suggest good value considering the location and service.

Landmarks

Naturidyll Hotel Hammerschmiede

Denkmal Gabrielen-Aussicht

Hotel-Restaurant Ammerhauser

Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt

Pension Hiesel-Villa Untersbergblick

Wildschweinbeobachtungspunkt