Shin-Liu Garden B&B vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Sapientia

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star9.5/1013 reviews

2.8 km (1.8 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Cleanliness

9.2

室內很乾淨，一點都不會造成困擾。

Location

9.7

環境清幽、安靜！

Close alternatives

Very close alternative

Sweet Home 101

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star6.8/107 reviews

View hotel

Sweet Home 101

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star9.4/1013 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Sapientia

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star9.5/1013 reviews

2.8 km (1.8 mi) from original

View hotel

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

Guangfu, TW

★ 0-star9.2/1080 reviews

1.1 km (0.69 mi) from original

View hotel

Key differences

Cleanliness

Sweet Home 1019.2

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel8.4

Value

Sapientia9.7

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel8.8

Sweet Home 101 amenity advantages

Concierge service

Sapientia amenity advantages

Laundry

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel amenity advantages

24-hour front deskMeeting/banquet facilitiesFamily rooms

Distance from original

The compared hotels differ by 1.7 km.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel: 1.1 km (0.69 mi)

Sapientia: 2.8 km (1.8 mi)

Detailed comparison

Category	Shin-Liu Garden B&B	Sweet Home 101	Sapientia	Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel
Guest score	6.8/10	9.4/10	9.5/10	9.2/10
Rooms	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Rooms were nicely renovated but comfort issues were noted with the foam mattress.
Cleanliness	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.2 室內很乾淨，一點都不會造成困擾。	8.4 Some reviews mentioned a cigarette smell in the room.
Location	—	9.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.7 環境清幽、安靜！	9.4 The location is praised for its peaceful environment and proximity to beautiful scenery.
Service	—	9.7 The host was very considerate and helped with luggage, and provided breakfast options in advance.	9.7 民宿的貓狗十分熱情，特別是小狗甜粿會負責大農大富自行車道導覽，十分有趣。	9.8 Service was described as good, with minor concerns about staff availability.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.7 早餐非常美味。	9.4 Breakfast options were varied and praised by guests.
Amenities & Facilities	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.4 The hotel offers great amenities including a wooden tub and bicycles for rent.
Value	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Pricing concerns were expressed, but overall value was seen as high.
Distance from original	Original hotel	2.1 km (1.3 mi)	2.8 km (1.8 mi)	1.1 km (0.69 mi)
Landmarks	Landmark data unavailable	洪華公園	糖業史料館	糖業史料館
Best suited for		Families	Quiet leisure travelers	Comfort-focused travelers

Guest score

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

6.8/10

Sweet Home 101

9.4/10

Sapientia

9.5/10

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.2/10

Rooms

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

8.8

Rooms were nicely renovated but comfort issues were noted with the foam mattress.

Cleanliness

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.2

室內很乾淨，一點都不會造成困擾。

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

8.4

Some reviews mentioned a cigarette smell in the room.

Location

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.7

環境清幽、安靜！

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.4

The location is praised for its peaceful environment and proximity to beautiful scenery.

Service

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.7

The host was very considerate and helped with luggage, and provided breakfast options in advance.

Sapientia

9.7

民宿的貓狗十分熱情，特別是小狗甜粿會負責大農大富自行車道導覽，十分有趣。

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.8

Service was described as good, with minor concerns about staff availability.

Sleep & Noise

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

—

Sapientia

—

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

—

Food & Breakfast

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.7

早餐非常美味。

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.4

Breakfast options were varied and praised by guests.

Amenities & Facilities

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.4

The hotel offers great amenities including a wooden tub and bicycles for rent.

Value

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

8.8

Pricing concerns were expressed, but overall value was seen as high.

Landmarks

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

Landmark data unavailable

Sweet Home 101

洪華公園

Sapientia

糖業史料館

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

糖業史料館

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star6.8/107 reviews

View hotel

Sweet Home 101

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star9.4/1013 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Sapientia

Guangfu, TW

★ 3-star9.5/1013 reviews

2.8 km (1.8 mi) from original

View hotel

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

Guangfu, TW

★ 0-star9.2/1080 reviews

1.1 km (0.69 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Shin-Liu Garden B&B	Sweet Home 101	Sapientia	Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel
Guest score	6.8/10	9.4/10	9.5/10	9.2/10
Rooms	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Rooms were nicely renovated but comfort issues were noted with the foam mattress.
Cleanliness	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.2 室內很乾淨，一點都不會造成困擾。	8.4 Some reviews mentioned a cigarette smell in the room.
Location	—	9.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.7 環境清幽、安靜！	9.4 The location is praised for its peaceful environment and proximity to beautiful scenery.
Service	—	9.7 The host was very considerate and helped with luggage, and provided breakfast options in advance.	9.7 民宿的貓狗十分熱情，特別是小狗甜粿會負責大農大富自行車道導覽，十分有趣。	9.8 Service was described as good, with minor concerns about staff availability.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.7 早餐非常美味。	9.4 Breakfast options were varied and praised by guests.
Amenities & Facilities	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.4 The hotel offers great amenities including a wooden tub and bicycles for rent.
Value	—	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Pricing concerns were expressed, but overall value was seen as high.
Distance from original	Original hotel	2.1 km (1.3 mi)	2.8 km (1.8 mi)	1.1 km (0.69 mi)
Landmarks	Landmark data unavailable	洪華公園	糖業史料館	糖業史料館
Best suited for		Families	Quiet leisure travelers	Comfort-focused travelers

Guest score

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

6.8/10

Sweet Home 101

9.4/10

Sapientia

9.5/10

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.2/10

Rooms

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

8.8

Rooms were nicely renovated but comfort issues were noted with the foam mattress.

Cleanliness

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.2

室內很乾淨，一點都不會造成困擾。

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

8.4

Some reviews mentioned a cigarette smell in the room.

Location

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.7

環境清幽、安靜！

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.4

The location is praised for its peaceful environment and proximity to beautiful scenery.

Service

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.7

The host was very considerate and helped with luggage, and provided breakfast options in advance.

Sapientia

9.7

民宿的貓狗十分熱情，特別是小狗甜粿會負責大農大富自行車道導覽，十分有趣。

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.8

Service was described as good, with minor concerns about staff availability.

Sleep & Noise

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

—

Sapientia

—

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

—

Food & Breakfast

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.7

早餐非常美味。

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.4

Breakfast options were varied and praised by guests.

Amenities & Facilities

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

9.4

The hotel offers great amenities including a wooden tub and bicycles for rent.

Value

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

—

Sweet Home 101

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sapientia

9.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

8.8

Pricing concerns were expressed, but overall value was seen as high.

Landmarks

Shin-Liu Garden B&B

Landmark data unavailable

Sweet Home 101

洪華公園

Sapientia

糖業史料館

Hualien Tourism Sugar Factory Hotel

糖業史料館