Our pick
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
Erice, IT
★ 3-star8.9/10996 reviews
3.5 km (2.2 mi) from original
English
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.9Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable, though some issues with temperature were noted.
Cleanliness
8.6Some reviews mentioned that rooms were clean, but there were issues with odor in the bathrooms.
Location
9.3Multiple reviews praised the excellent location and peaceful surroundings.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Il Carmine Dimora Storica8.9
Hotel Elimo7.5
Cleanliness
Il Carmine Dimora Storica8.6
Hotel Elimo7.1
Food & Breakfast
Hotel Elimo9.6
Il Carmine Dimora Storica8.8
Amenities & Facilities
Hotel Elimo9.1
Il Carmine Dimora Storica8.3
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerBeach
Hotel Elimo amenity advantages
24-hour front deskLaundry
Il Carmine Dimora Storica amenity advantages
Electric vehicle charging station
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 3.1 km.
DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente: 0.37 km (0.23 mi)
Il Carmine Dimora Storica: 3.5 km (2.2 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
8.8/10DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
10/10Hotel Elimo
8.7/10Il Carmine Dimora Storica
8.9/10Rooms
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
7.5Significant issues with room comfort and quality were mentioned.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
8.9Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable, though some issues with temperature were noted.
Cleanliness
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
7.1Room cleanliness was below standard; visible issues noted.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
8.6Some reviews mentioned that rooms were clean, but there were issues with odor in the bathrooms.
Location
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
9.6Excellent location with easy access to historical sites and restaurants.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
9.3Multiple reviews praised the excellent location and peaceful surroundings.
Service
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
9.1Service was friendly overall, but there were some notable issues.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
9.3Many guests highlighted the friendly and accommodating staff.
Sleep & Noise
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
—Il Carmine Dimora Storica
—Food & Breakfast
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
9.6Breakfast was excellent; positive sentiment overall.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
8.8Breakfast was generally well-reviewed, but a few noted that it could be more varied.
Amenities & Facilities
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier; further details not mentioned.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
8.3Some amenities were lacking, like the breakfast variety and Wi-Fi quality.
Value
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
—DeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
—Hotel Elimo
9.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Il Carmine Dimora Storica
8.9Guests felt the experience matched the price, though some saw room for improvement.
Landmarks
Il Giardino del Sole - Erice mare
Landmark data unavailableDeCaro Casa Mare di Ponente
Landmark data unavailableHotel Elimo
Padre PioIl Carmine Dimora Storica
Porta Castellammare