Our pick
Great Cistern Beach Village
Marsh Harbour, BS
★ 3-star9.3/1036 reviews
6.9 km (4.3 mi) from original
English
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.2This was a great facility.
Cleanliness
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
9.7Beautiful secluded place near Marsh Harbour.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
Marsh Harbour, BS
★ 0-star10/101 reviews
Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
Marsh Harbour, BS
★ 0-star9.7/103 reviews
1.5 km (0.93 mi) from original
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
Marsh Harbour, BS
★ 3-star8/10112 reviews
0.80 km (0.50 mi) from original
Our pick
Great Cistern Beach Village
Marsh Harbour, BS
★ 3-star9.3/1036 reviews
6.9 km (4.3 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Great Cistern Beach Village9.2
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina7.4
Cleanliness
Great Cistern Beach Village9.2
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina6.5
Location
Great Cistern Beach Village9.7
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina9.0
Food & Breakfast
Great Cistern Beach Village9.2
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina8.5
Amenities & Facilities
Great Cistern Beach Village9.2
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina7.5
Value
Great Cistern Beach Village9.2
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina7.4
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican amenity advantages
Hot tub/Jacuzzi
Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views! amenity advantages
Pets allowed
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina amenity advantages
24-hour front deskConcierge serviceFitness facilitiesConference spaceWater skiing nearby
Great Cistern Beach Village amenity advantages
WiFi availableFree WiFiShuttle service (additional charge)
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 6.1 km.
Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina: 0.80 km (0.50 mi)
Great Cistern Beach Village: 6.9 km (4.3 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
10/10Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
9.7/10Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
8/10Great Cistern Beach Village
9.3/10Rooms
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
7.4The room layout was nice, but significant issues were noted, including water pressure and leaking doors.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.2This was a great facility.
Cleanliness
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
6.5The review mentioned moldy shower doors and poor maintenance which indicates a lack of cleanliness.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
9.0The location is mentioned as having few nice hotels in the area, suggesting a reasonable but limited choice.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.7Beautiful secluded place near Marsh Harbour.
Service
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
9.4Outstanding staff was mentioned, particularly noting Eddie's excellent service.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.7The host went above and beyond to accommodate our group.
Sleep & Noise
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
—Great Cistern Beach Village
—Food & Breakfast
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
8.5No specific mentions, assumed standard for this hotel tier.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
7.5Kitchen equipment was insufficient, and amenities were noted as needing improvement.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
—Harbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
—Abaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
7.4Based on the condition and services, the hotel may not meet expectations for the price.
Great Cistern Beach Village
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Landmarks
Private Oceanfront, beach, dock and Hottub - The Perky Pelican
Marsh Harbour Memorial GardenHarbour Beach Villa - large dock & great views!
Marsh Harbour Memorial GardenAbaco Beach Resort and Boat Harbour Marina
Marsh Harbour Memorial GardenGreat Cistern Beach Village
No landmark signals returned