Our pick
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
Negril, JM
★ 0-star8.2/10213 reviews
0.86 km (0.54 mi) from original
English
Andre's Guest House vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.4Rooms were described as comfortable and as good as pictures showed, although some had issues.
Cleanliness
8.0Some reviews mentioned issues with upkeep, such as a ripped screen and a broken lock.
Location
8.9Reviews highlighted the beautiful beach location and proximity to attractions.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms8.4
Westport Cottage7.1
Cleanliness
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms8.0
Westport Cottage4.7
Location
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms8.9
Sand and Blue Seas7.9
Food & Breakfast
Sand and Blue Seas7.9
Westport Cottage6.7
Amenities & Facilities
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms8.0
Westport Cottage7.2
Value
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms8.0
Westport Cottage6.6
Sand and Blue Seas amenity advantages
Swimming poolHot tub/JacuzziFitness facilities (surcharge)
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms amenity advantages
Room serviceSpa/wellness centerLaundryLuggage storageBabysitting/child services
Westport Cottage amenity advantages
24-hour front desk
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Andre's Guest House
7.8/10Sand and Blue Seas
7.7/10Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.2/10Westport Cottage
7.1/10Rooms
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
7.8Room was better than expected; few minor issues.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.4Rooms were described as comfortable and as good as pictures showed, although some had issues.
Westport Cottage
7.1Cottages match photos; some discomfort due to heat without air conditioning.
Cleanliness
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
6.9No specific mention of cleanliness; adjusted score due to overall sentiment.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.0Some reviews mentioned issues with upkeep, such as a ripped screen and a broken lock.
Westport Cottage
4.7Negative sentiment regarding cleanliness was implied.
Location
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
7.9No specific mention of location; general sentiment suggests acceptable standards.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.9Reviews highlighted the beautiful beach location and proximity to attractions.
Westport Cottage
8.7The beach is usable and beautiful, enhancing the location's appeal.
Service
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
8.3Staff were friendly and hospitable.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.4Most reviews noted friendly and helpful staff, but lack of staff presence in the mornings was a concern.
Westport Cottage
8.2The owner is described as very nice; service can be improved, but is supportive.
Sleep & Noise
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
—Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
—Westport Cottage
—Food & Breakfast
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
7.9Restaurant on property was good.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
7.5Food was described as average and expensive despite the hotel context.
Westport Cottage
6.7No specific mention of food and beverage quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
7.4No specific mention of amenities; average quality expected.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.0Amenities described as standard for the hotel, though bar prices raised concerns.
Westport Cottage
7.2Amenities are adequate but could be improved (only a fan available).
Value
Andre's Guest House
—Sand and Blue Seas
7.8No specific mention of value for money; reasonable quality suggested.
Roots Cafe Negril Rooms
8.0Some reviews mentioned food and drink pricing as high compared to quality.
Westport Cottage
6.6Value for money is fair considering the pros and cons.
Landmarks
Andre's Guest House
Palm Grove MannorSand and Blue Seas
Palm Grove MannorRoots Cafe Negril Rooms
Palm Grove MannorWestport Cottage
Negril Public Park