Our pick
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
Vagamon, IN
★ 2-star8.7/10275 reviews
4.5 km (2.8 mi) from original
English
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.0Some rooms were considered normal and not worth the money, a slight downgrade suggested by multiple reviews.
Cleanliness
8.0The state of the washroom in one review indicated it wasn't up to the mark due to a constant smell.
Service
9.4Staff is described as super friendly and helpful, adding positively to the service experience.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home
Vagamon, IN
★ 0-star7.9/1027 reviews
6.0 km (3.7 mi) from original
Our pick
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
Vagamon, IN
★ 2-star8.7/10275 reviews
4.5 km (2.8 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Cleanliness
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts8.0
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home6.5
Location
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home9.6
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts8.9
Food & Breakfast
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts8.0
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home6.5
Amenities & Facilities
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts8.9
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home6.8
Value
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts8.9
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home7.9
Vanilla County amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerConcierge serviceLaundrySun loungers or beach chairs
Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts amenity advantages
24-hour front deskMeeting/banquet facilitiesElectric vehicle charging station
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 5.8 km.
Vanilla County: 0.19 km (0.12 mi)
Vagamon Misty Holiday Home: 6.0 km (3.7 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
10/10Vagamon Misty Holiday Home
7.9/10Vanilla County
9.4/10Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.7/10Rooms
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
7.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.0Some rooms were considered normal and not worth the money, a slight downgrade suggested by multiple reviews.
Cleanliness
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
6.5Housekeeping lapse noted: sheets for blankets were not provided until requested, indicating below-average attention to room setup.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.0The state of the washroom in one review indicated it wasn't up to the mark due to a constant smell.
Location
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
9.6Great view highlighted in the review, indicating an excellent location/view quality.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.9Location is mentioned favorably but has a disadvantage if lacking personal transport.
Service
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
9.8Very helpful and friendly caretaker; strong positive personal service from staff.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
9.4Staff is described as super friendly and helpful, adding positively to the service experience.
Sleep & Noise
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
—Vagamon Misty Holiday Home
—Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
—Food & Breakfast
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
6.5No restaurant on the property, a negative for food and beverage options.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.0Food quality varied with experiences of cold food and limited options.
Amenities & Facilities
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
6.8No on-site restaurant reported, reducing perceived amenities.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.9Amenities mentioned include swimming pool, but some food options were limited.
Value
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Not enough guest feedbackVagamon Misty Holiday Home
7.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Vanilla County
—Winter Vale Green Stay Resorts
8.9Value for money is viewed positively in several reviews, indicating satisfaction.
Landmarks
Colonel's Retreat by The Almanac
Zip Line VagamonVagamon Misty Holiday Home
Thangal ParaVanilla County
Landmark data unavailableWinter Vale Green Stay Resorts
Tiger