Our pick
English
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.6Bedroom was spacious with clean bedding and extra bedding provided, but bed was reported as too hard and bathtub drained poorly.
Cleanliness
9.0House was described as neat and clean overall, but shower head was dirty/grimy causing low pressure and some pooling in the tub.
Location
10.0Neighbourhood was peaceful and neighbours were friendly; location contributed positively to the stay.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
Old Harbour, JM
★ 0-star5/101 reviews
0.30 km (0.19 mi) from original
Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
Old Harbour, JM
★ 0-star9.7/109 reviews
0.12 km (0.07 mi) from original
Our pick
Key differences
Location
The Surada Bay10.0
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor8.9
Service
The Surada Bay9.4
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor8.9
Food & Breakfast
The Surada Bay9.4
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor8.9
Amenities & Facilities
The Surada Bay9.6
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor8.9
Value
The Surada Bay9.4
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor8.9
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet amenity advantages
Non-smoking rooms
The Surada Bay amenity advantages
WiFi availableFree WiFi
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9/10Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
5/10Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
9.7/10The Surada Bay
9.4/10Rooms
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
8.6Bedroom was spacious with clean bedding and extra bedding provided, but bed was reported as too hard and bathtub drained poorly.
Cleanliness
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
9.0House was described as neat and clean overall, but shower head was dirty/grimy causing low pressure and some pooling in the tub.
Location
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
10.0Neighbourhood was peaceful and neighbours were friendly; location contributed positively to the stay.
Service
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Host was described as super helpful; guest praised service and said they will definitely be back.
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
9.4Standard quality for this hotel tier
Sleep & Noise
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
—Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
—Food & Breakfast
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
9.4Standard quality for this hotel tier
Amenities & Facilities
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
9.6Useful amenities like bedside lamps with USB outlets and extra bedding noted; lacking a few practical items (clothing hangers, standard-height ironing board).
Value
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
8.9Standard quality for this hotel tier
Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
—Colbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
—The Surada Bay
9.4Standard quality for this hotel tier
Landmarks
Charming refuge at Colbeck Manor
Colbeck Castle (1680)Humming Bird Inn-Homely and quiet
Old Harbour ParkColbeck Manor - The Geenie Gates
Colbeck Castle (1680)The Surada Bay
Colbeck Castle (1680)