Nickels Garden Villas vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

West Gates Get Away

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.5/1013 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Cleanliness

9.3

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Location

10.0

Property is in a great location.

Service

9.8

The host was very welcoming and awesome.

Close alternatives

Very close alternative

Aldae Inn

Better if you care more about Rooms, Value.

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Nickels Garden Villas

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9/1051 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

West Gates Get Away

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.5/1013 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View hotel

Aldae Inn

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.4/1017 reviews

2.0 km (1.2 mi) from original

View hotel

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.1/1041 reviews

5.6 km (3.5 mi) from original

View hotel

Trade-offs

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.

Aldae Inn

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Rooms9.6

Value9.6

Key differences

Rooms

Aldae Inn9.6

Nickels Garden Villas8.1

Cleanliness

West Gates Get Away9.3

Nickels Garden Villas8.6

Location

West Gates Get Away10.0

Aldae Inn8.7

Service

West Gates Get Away9.8

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security9.3

Food & Breakfast

West Gates Get Away9.8

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security8.8

Amenities & Facilities

West Gates Get Away9.8

Nickels Garden Villas8.6

Value

Aldae Inn9.6

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security8.7

Nickels Garden Villas amenity advantages

24-hour front deskBusiness centerSpa/wellness centerBreakfast in the room

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security amenity advantages

Swimming pool

Distance from original

The compared hotels differ by 3.6 km.

Aldae Inn: 2.0 km (1.2 mi)

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security: 5.6 km (3.5 mi)

Detailed comparison

Category	Nickels Garden Villas	West Gates Get Away	Aldae Inn	Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security
Guest score	9/10	9.5/10	9.4/10	9.1/10
Rooms	8.1 Issues with bed height and air conditioning in the living room.	8.8 Disappointing due to lack of AC in the sitting room.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.3 The condo is on the ground floor just what my dad needed.
Cleanliness	8.6 The place was clean and decorated nicely.	9.3 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.7 Facility is very clean.	9.3 The place was spotless clean.
Location	9.7 The location was good, area nice.	10.0 Property is in a great location.	8.7 The location is not bad and it's a good distance from the town.	9.3 Close to everything and tucked away.
Service	9.6 Helpful service, they retrieved a forgotten package.	9.8 The host was very welcoming and awesome.	9.7 The host Daemar was amazing.	9.3 Shana is a great host, and the security was very respectful.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	9.1 No specific feedback; assumed standard for this hotel tier.	9.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	8.6 All utensils provided, complimentary water, but issues with remote access.	9.8 Wonderful rooftop with an amazing view.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value	9.1 A decent value considering location and amenities.	8.8 Disappointing especially after inability to get a refund.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Distance from original	Original hotel	2.1 km (1.3 mi)	2.0 km (1.2 mi)	5.6 km (3.5 mi)
Landmarks	Rastafari Indigenous Village	West Gate Park	Cornwall Court Park	Old Montego Fort
Best suited for	Comfort-focused travelers	Comfort-focused travelers	Families	Sightseeing travelers

Guest score

Nickels Garden Villas

9/10

West Gates Get Away

9.5/10

Aldae Inn

9.4/10

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.1/10

Rooms

Nickels Garden Villas

8.1

Issues with bed height and air conditioning in the living room.

West Gates Get Away

8.8

Disappointing due to lack of AC in the sitting room.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

The condo is on the ground floor just what my dad needed.

Cleanliness

Nickels Garden Villas

8.6

The place was clean and decorated nicely.

West Gates Get Away

9.3

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Aldae Inn

8.7

Facility is very clean.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

The place was spotless clean.

Location

Nickels Garden Villas

9.7

The location was good, area nice.

West Gates Get Away

10.0

Property is in a great location.

Aldae Inn

8.7

The location is not bad and it's a good distance from the town.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

Close to everything and tucked away.

Service

Nickels Garden Villas

9.6

Helpful service, they retrieved a forgotten package.

West Gates Get Away

9.8

The host was very welcoming and awesome.

Aldae Inn

9.7

The host Daemar was amazing.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

Shana is a great host, and the security was very respectful.

Sleep & Noise

Nickels Garden Villas

—

West Gates Get Away

—

Aldae Inn

—

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

—

Food & Breakfast

Nickels Garden Villas

9.1

No specific feedback; assumed standard for this hotel tier.

West Gates Get Away

9.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

8.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Nickels Garden Villas

8.6

All utensils provided, complimentary water, but issues with remote access.

West Gates Get Away

9.8

Wonderful rooftop with an amazing view.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

8.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Value

Nickels Garden Villas

9.1

A decent value considering location and amenities.

West Gates Get Away

8.8

Disappointing especially after inability to get a refund.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

8.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Landmarks

Nickels Garden Villas

Rastafari Indigenous Village

West Gates Get Away

West Gate Park

Aldae Inn

Cornwall Court Park

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

Old Montego Fort

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Nickels Garden Villas

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9/1051 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

West Gates Get Away

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.5/1013 reviews

2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original

View hotel

Aldae Inn

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.4/1017 reviews

2.0 km (1.2 mi) from original

View hotel

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

Montego Bay, JM

★ 4-star9.1/1041 reviews

5.6 km (3.5 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Nickels Garden Villas	West Gates Get Away	Aldae Inn	Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security
Guest score	9/10	9.5/10	9.4/10	9.1/10
Rooms	8.1 Issues with bed height and air conditioning in the living room.	8.8 Disappointing due to lack of AC in the sitting room.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.3 The condo is on the ground floor just what my dad needed.
Cleanliness	8.6 The place was clean and decorated nicely.	9.3 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.7 Facility is very clean.	9.3 The place was spotless clean.
Location	9.7 The location was good, area nice.	10.0 Property is in a great location.	8.7 The location is not bad and it's a good distance from the town.	9.3 Close to everything and tucked away.
Service	9.6 Helpful service, they retrieved a forgotten package.	9.8 The host was very welcoming and awesome.	9.7 The host Daemar was amazing.	9.3 Shana is a great host, and the security was very respectful.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	9.1 No specific feedback; assumed standard for this hotel tier.	9.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	8.6 All utensils provided, complimentary water, but issues with remote access.	9.8 Wonderful rooftop with an amazing view.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value	9.1 A decent value considering location and amenities.	8.8 Disappointing especially after inability to get a refund.	9.6 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	8.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Distance from original	Original hotel	2.1 km (1.3 mi)	2.0 km (1.2 mi)	5.6 km (3.5 mi)
Landmarks	Rastafari Indigenous Village	West Gate Park	Cornwall Court Park	Old Montego Fort
Best suited for	Comfort-focused travelers	Comfort-focused travelers	Families	Sightseeing travelers

Guest score

Nickels Garden Villas

9/10

West Gates Get Away

9.5/10

Aldae Inn

9.4/10

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.1/10

Rooms

Nickels Garden Villas

8.1

Issues with bed height and air conditioning in the living room.

West Gates Get Away

8.8

Disappointing due to lack of AC in the sitting room.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

The condo is on the ground floor just what my dad needed.

Cleanliness

Nickels Garden Villas

8.6

The place was clean and decorated nicely.

West Gates Get Away

9.3

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Aldae Inn

8.7

Facility is very clean.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

The place was spotless clean.

Location

Nickels Garden Villas

9.7

The location was good, area nice.

West Gates Get Away

10.0

Property is in a great location.

Aldae Inn

8.7

The location is not bad and it's a good distance from the town.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

Close to everything and tucked away.

Service

Nickels Garden Villas

9.6

Helpful service, they retrieved a forgotten package.

West Gates Get Away

9.8

The host was very welcoming and awesome.

Aldae Inn

9.7

The host Daemar was amazing.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

9.3

Shana is a great host, and the security was very respectful.

Sleep & Noise

Nickels Garden Villas

—

West Gates Get Away

—

Aldae Inn

—

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

—

Food & Breakfast

Nickels Garden Villas

9.1

No specific feedback; assumed standard for this hotel tier.

West Gates Get Away

9.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

8.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Nickels Garden Villas

8.6

All utensils provided, complimentary water, but issues with remote access.

West Gates Get Away

9.8

Wonderful rooftop with an amazing view.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

8.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Value

Nickels Garden Villas

9.1

A decent value considering location and amenities.

West Gates Get Away

8.8

Disappointing especially after inability to get a refund.

Aldae Inn

9.6

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

8.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Landmarks

Nickels Garden Villas

Rastafari Indigenous Village

West Gates Get Away

West Gate Park

Aldae Inn

Cornwall Court Park

Falcon Oceanview 2br Condo-Airport Transportation Available-24-7Security

Old Montego Fort