Buttermilchalm vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Landhaus Theresia

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 4-star9.7/10156 reviews

1.4 km (0.89 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

9.7

Guests found the rooms spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.

Cleanliness

9.7

Guests praised the cleanliness and order of the apartment.

Location

9.7

The apartment is located in a quiet village with beautiful views.

Close alternatives

Very close alternative

Hotel Pension Barbara

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Buttermilchalm

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 3-star8.6/10298 reviews

View hotel

Hotel Pension Barbara

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 3-star9.6/10366 reviews

1.2 km (0.75 mi) from original

View hotel

Pension Edelweiss

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 2-star8.5/10704 reviews

0.79 km (0.49 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Landhaus Theresia

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 4-star9.7/10156 reviews

1.4 km (0.89 mi) from original

View hotel

Key differences

Rooms

Landhaus Theresia9.7

Pension Edelweiss7.7

Cleanliness

Landhaus Theresia9.7

Pension Edelweiss8.2

Location

Landhaus Theresia9.7

Pension Edelweiss8.2

Service

Hotel Pension Barbara9.9

Pension Edelweiss9.2

Food & Breakfast

Hotel Pension Barbara9.4

Buttermilchalm8.1

Amenities & Facilities

Landhaus Theresia9.7

Buttermilchalm7.5

Value

Hotel Pension Barbara9.9

Buttermilchalm8.1

Buttermilchalm amenity advantages

Physical distancing in dining areas

Hotel Pension Barbara amenity advantages

SaunaAirport shuttle

Detailed comparison

Category	Buttermilchalm	Hotel Pension Barbara	Pension Edelweiss	Landhaus Theresia
Guest score	8.6/10	9.6/10	8.5/10	9.7/10
Rooms	8.1 There were complaints about a lack of amenities and the outdated condition of some rooms.	9.4 Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-maintained.	7.7 Some comments indicated rooms being outdated and beds uncomfortable.	9.7 Guests found the rooms spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.
Cleanliness	9.1 The room was reported to be very clean, which contributes positively to the overall experience.	9.4 The rooms are described as very clean and tidy, with few mentions of issues.	8.2 Most reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, although some referred to outdated furniture.	9.7 Guests praised the cleanliness and order of the apartment.
Location	9.6 The location received multiple praises for its views and proximity to trails.	9.4 Proximity to hiking paths and a supermarket adds convenience.	8.2 Convenient location next to the highway received positive mentions.	9.7 The apartment is located in a quiet village with beautiful views.
Service	9.3 The hosts were mentioned as very kind, leading to a positive impression of service.	9.9 Multiple reviews highlight the warm, helpful nature of the hosts.	9.2 Multiple guests praised the owner for their friendliness and helpfulness.	9.9 Guests mentioned the owners are very nice and responsive.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	8.1 Limited breakfast options and the restaurant being closed were noted as downsides.	9.4 Reviews mention a very good breakfast with various options.	8.7 Breakfast options were frequently praised for quality and variety.	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	7.5 Several amenities were missing such as a hair dryer and kettle, impacting overall satisfaction.	9.4 Facilities include a nice breakfast and areas for children.	8.7 Amenities were generally well-received, despite some suggestions for improvement.	9.7 The apartment was well-equipped with everything necessary for a stay.
Value	8.1 Guests felt that the price for breakfast and lack of provided services did not align with expectations.	9.9 Guests feel they received excellent value for what they paid.	8.7 Value for money was seen positively, with good breakfast and spacious rooms.	9.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Distance from original	Original hotel	1.2 km (0.75 mi)	0.79 km (0.49 mi)	1.4 km (0.89 mi)
Landmarks	Seepark St. Martin	Seepark St. Martin	Seepark St. Martin	Alter Unterbichlhof
Best suited for	Quiet leisure travelers	Families	Comfort-focused travelers	Families

Guest score

Buttermilchalm

8.6/10

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.6/10

Pension Edelweiss

8.5/10

Landhaus Theresia

9.7/10

Rooms

Buttermilchalm

8.1

There were complaints about a lack of amenities and the outdated condition of some rooms.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-maintained.

Pension Edelweiss

7.7

Some comments indicated rooms being outdated and beds uncomfortable.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

Guests found the rooms spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.

Cleanliness

Buttermilchalm

9.1

The room was reported to be very clean, which contributes positively to the overall experience.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

The rooms are described as very clean and tidy, with few mentions of issues.

Pension Edelweiss

8.2

Most reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, although some referred to outdated furniture.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

Guests praised the cleanliness and order of the apartment.

Location

Buttermilchalm

9.6

The location received multiple praises for its views and proximity to trails.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Proximity to hiking paths and a supermarket adds convenience.

Pension Edelweiss

8.2

Convenient location next to the highway received positive mentions.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

The apartment is located in a quiet village with beautiful views.

Service

Buttermilchalm

9.3

The hosts were mentioned as very kind, leading to a positive impression of service.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.9

Multiple reviews highlight the warm, helpful nature of the hosts.

Pension Edelweiss

9.2

Multiple guests praised the owner for their friendliness and helpfulness.

Landhaus Theresia

9.9

Guests mentioned the owners are very nice and responsive.

Sleep & Noise

Buttermilchalm

—

Hotel Pension Barbara

—

Pension Edelweiss

—

Landhaus Theresia

—

Food & Breakfast

Buttermilchalm

8.1

Limited breakfast options and the restaurant being closed were noted as downsides.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Reviews mention a very good breakfast with various options.

Pension Edelweiss

8.7

Breakfast options were frequently praised for quality and variety.

Landhaus Theresia

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Buttermilchalm

7.5

Several amenities were missing such as a hair dryer and kettle, impacting overall satisfaction.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Facilities include a nice breakfast and areas for children.

Pension Edelweiss

8.7

Amenities were generally well-received, despite some suggestions for improvement.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

The apartment was well-equipped with everything necessary for a stay.

Value

Buttermilchalm

8.1

Guests felt that the price for breakfast and lack of provided services did not align with expectations.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.9

Guests feel they received excellent value for what they paid.

Pension Edelweiss

8.7

Value for money was seen positively, with good breakfast and spacious rooms.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Landmarks

Buttermilchalm

Seepark St. Martin

Hotel Pension Barbara

Seepark St. Martin

Pension Edelweiss

Seepark St. Martin

Landhaus Theresia

Alter Unterbichlhof

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Buttermilchalm

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 3-star8.6/10298 reviews

View hotel

Hotel Pension Barbara

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 3-star9.6/10366 reviews

1.2 km (0.75 mi) from original

View hotel

Pension Edelweiss

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 2-star8.5/10704 reviews

0.79 km (0.49 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Landhaus Theresia

Sankt Martin am Tennengebirge, AT

★ 4-star9.7/10156 reviews

1.4 km (0.89 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Buttermilchalm	Hotel Pension Barbara	Pension Edelweiss	Landhaus Theresia
Guest score	8.6/10	9.6/10	8.5/10	9.7/10
Rooms	8.1 There were complaints about a lack of amenities and the outdated condition of some rooms.	9.4 Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-maintained.	7.7 Some comments indicated rooms being outdated and beds uncomfortable.	9.7 Guests found the rooms spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.
Cleanliness	9.1 The room was reported to be very clean, which contributes positively to the overall experience.	9.4 The rooms are described as very clean and tidy, with few mentions of issues.	8.2 Most reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, although some referred to outdated furniture.	9.7 Guests praised the cleanliness and order of the apartment.
Location	9.6 The location received multiple praises for its views and proximity to trails.	9.4 Proximity to hiking paths and a supermarket adds convenience.	8.2 Convenient location next to the highway received positive mentions.	9.7 The apartment is located in a quiet village with beautiful views.
Service	9.3 The hosts were mentioned as very kind, leading to a positive impression of service.	9.9 Multiple reviews highlight the warm, helpful nature of the hosts.	9.2 Multiple guests praised the owner for their friendliness and helpfulness.	9.9 Guests mentioned the owners are very nice and responsive.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	8.1 Limited breakfast options and the restaurant being closed were noted as downsides.	9.4 Reviews mention a very good breakfast with various options.	8.7 Breakfast options were frequently praised for quality and variety.	9.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	7.5 Several amenities were missing such as a hair dryer and kettle, impacting overall satisfaction.	9.4 Facilities include a nice breakfast and areas for children.	8.7 Amenities were generally well-received, despite some suggestions for improvement.	9.7 The apartment was well-equipped with everything necessary for a stay.
Value	8.1 Guests felt that the price for breakfast and lack of provided services did not align with expectations.	9.9 Guests feel they received excellent value for what they paid.	8.7 Value for money was seen positively, with good breakfast and spacious rooms.	9.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Distance from original	Original hotel	1.2 km (0.75 mi)	0.79 km (0.49 mi)	1.4 km (0.89 mi)
Landmarks	Seepark St. Martin	Seepark St. Martin	Seepark St. Martin	Alter Unterbichlhof
Best suited for	Quiet leisure travelers	Families	Comfort-focused travelers	Families

Guest score

Buttermilchalm

8.6/10

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.6/10

Pension Edelweiss

8.5/10

Landhaus Theresia

9.7/10

Rooms

Buttermilchalm

8.1

There were complaints about a lack of amenities and the outdated condition of some rooms.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-maintained.

Pension Edelweiss

7.7

Some comments indicated rooms being outdated and beds uncomfortable.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

Guests found the rooms spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.

Cleanliness

Buttermilchalm

9.1

The room was reported to be very clean, which contributes positively to the overall experience.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

The rooms are described as very clean and tidy, with few mentions of issues.

Pension Edelweiss

8.2

Most reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, although some referred to outdated furniture.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

Guests praised the cleanliness and order of the apartment.

Location

Buttermilchalm

9.6

The location received multiple praises for its views and proximity to trails.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Proximity to hiking paths and a supermarket adds convenience.

Pension Edelweiss

8.2

Convenient location next to the highway received positive mentions.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

The apartment is located in a quiet village with beautiful views.

Service

Buttermilchalm

9.3

The hosts were mentioned as very kind, leading to a positive impression of service.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.9

Multiple reviews highlight the warm, helpful nature of the hosts.

Pension Edelweiss

9.2

Multiple guests praised the owner for their friendliness and helpfulness.

Landhaus Theresia

9.9

Guests mentioned the owners are very nice and responsive.

Sleep & Noise

Buttermilchalm

—

Hotel Pension Barbara

—

Pension Edelweiss

—

Landhaus Theresia

—

Food & Breakfast

Buttermilchalm

8.1

Limited breakfast options and the restaurant being closed were noted as downsides.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Reviews mention a very good breakfast with various options.

Pension Edelweiss

8.7

Breakfast options were frequently praised for quality and variety.

Landhaus Theresia

9.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Buttermilchalm

7.5

Several amenities were missing such as a hair dryer and kettle, impacting overall satisfaction.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.4

Facilities include a nice breakfast and areas for children.

Pension Edelweiss

8.7

Amenities were generally well-received, despite some suggestions for improvement.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

The apartment was well-equipped with everything necessary for a stay.

Value

Buttermilchalm

8.1

Guests felt that the price for breakfast and lack of provided services did not align with expectations.

Hotel Pension Barbara

9.9

Guests feel they received excellent value for what they paid.

Pension Edelweiss

8.7

Value for money was seen positively, with good breakfast and spacious rooms.

Landhaus Theresia

9.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Landmarks

Buttermilchalm

Seepark St. Martin

Hotel Pension Barbara

Seepark St. Martin

Pension Edelweiss

Seepark St. Martin

Landhaus Theresia

Alter Unterbichlhof