Rose Hall vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7.6/1021 reviews

1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

7.7

The room was noted as clean and tidy.

Cleanliness

8.2

The reviews consistently mention that everything is clean and tidy.

Location

7.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Close alternatives

No close alternative was identified for this preference.

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Rose Hall

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7/101 reviews

View hotel

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star5.6/1022 reviews

1.3 km (0.82 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7.6/1021 reviews

1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original

View hotel

Seacastles Apartments

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7.4/1025 reviews

1.7 km (1.1 mi) from original

View hotel

Trade-offs

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Amenities & Facilities6.7

Seacastles Apartments

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Amenities & Facilities7.8

Key differences

Rooms

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals7.7

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica4.7

Cleanliness

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals8.2

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica4.2

Location

Seacastles Apartments7.8

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica7.2

Service

Seacastles Apartments7.7

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica6.2

Food & Breakfast

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals8.2

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica4.7

Amenities & Facilities

Seacastles Apartments7.8

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals6.2

Value

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals8.2

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica4.7

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica amenity advantages

Free WiFiConcierge serviceCouples/private dining

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals amenity advantages

On private beach

Detailed comparison

Category	Rose Hall	Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica	Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals	Seacastles Apartments
Guest score	7/10	5.6/10	7.6/10	7.4/10
Rooms	Not enough guest feedback	4.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.	7.7 The room was noted as clean and tidy.	7.2 The apartment was small but had everything we needed.
Cleanliness	Not enough guest feedback	4.2 The mention of leaving keys in doors raises safety concerns, reflecting negatively on the hotel's management.	8.2 The reviews consistently mention that everything is clean and tidy.	6.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location	Not enough guest feedback	7.2 Amazing location with beautiful mountain and ocean views, enhancing the overall appeal.	7.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.8 Sea Castles is conveniently located about 15 minutes drive from MBJ Airport.
Service	Not enough guest feedback	6.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier, though service expectations were not highlighted.	7.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.7 All the staff were very kind and accommodating.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	Not enough guest feedback	4.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.	8.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	Not enough guest feedback	6.7 Great amenities like a pool and tennis courts, enhancing guest experience.	6.2 No chairs by the pool side noted as a downside.	7.8 The kitchenette was well stocked; the pool was well maintained.
Value	Not enough guest feedback	4.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.	8.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.7 We felt we got a good value for what we paid.
Distance from original	Original hotel	1.3 km (0.82 mi)	1.8 km (1.1 mi)	1.7 km (1.1 mi)
Landmarks	Rose Hall Great House (1770)	Rose Hall Great House (1770)	Rose Hall Great House (1770)	Rose Hall Great House (1770)
Best suited for			Comfort-focused travelers	Sightseeing travelers

Guest score

Rose Hall

7/10

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

5.6/10

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.6/10

Seacastles Apartments

7.4/10

Rooms

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.7

The room was noted as clean and tidy.

Seacastles Apartments

7.2

The apartment was small but had everything we needed.

Cleanliness

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.2

The mention of leaving keys in doors raises safety concerns, reflecting negatively on the hotel's management.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

8.2

The reviews consistently mention that everything is clean and tidy.

Seacastles Apartments

6.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Location

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

7.2

Amazing location with beautiful mountain and ocean views, enhancing the overall appeal.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.8

Sea Castles is conveniently located about 15 minutes drive from MBJ Airport.

Service

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

6.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier, though service expectations were not highlighted.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.7

All the staff were very kind and accommodating.

Sleep & Noise

Rose Hall

—

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

—

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

—

Seacastles Apartments

—

Food & Breakfast

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

8.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

6.7

Great amenities like a pool and tennis courts, enhancing guest experience.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

6.2

No chairs by the pool side noted as a downside.

Seacastles Apartments

7.8

The kitchenette was well stocked; the pool was well maintained.

Value

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

8.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.7

We felt we got a good value for what we paid.

Landmarks

Rose Hall

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Seacastles Apartments

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Rose Hall

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7/101 reviews

View hotel

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star5.6/1022 reviews

1.3 km (0.82 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7.6/1021 reviews

1.8 km (1.1 mi) from original

View hotel

Seacastles Apartments

Montego Bay, JM

★ 3-star7.4/1025 reviews

1.7 km (1.1 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Rose Hall	Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica	Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals	Seacastles Apartments
Guest score	7/10	5.6/10	7.6/10	7.4/10
Rooms	Not enough guest feedback	4.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.	7.7 The room was noted as clean and tidy.	7.2 The apartment was small but had everything we needed.
Cleanliness	Not enough guest feedback	4.2 The mention of leaving keys in doors raises safety concerns, reflecting negatively on the hotel's management.	8.2 The reviews consistently mention that everything is clean and tidy.	6.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location	Not enough guest feedback	7.2 Amazing location with beautiful mountain and ocean views, enhancing the overall appeal.	7.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.8 Sea Castles is conveniently located about 15 minutes drive from MBJ Airport.
Service	Not enough guest feedback	6.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier, though service expectations were not highlighted.	7.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.7 All the staff were very kind and accommodating.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	Not enough guest feedback	4.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.	8.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	Not enough guest feedback	6.7 Great amenities like a pool and tennis courts, enhancing guest experience.	6.2 No chairs by the pool side noted as a downside.	7.8 The kitchenette was well stocked; the pool was well maintained.
Value	Not enough guest feedback	4.7 Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.	8.2 Standard quality for this hotel tier.	7.7 We felt we got a good value for what we paid.
Distance from original	Original hotel	1.3 km (0.82 mi)	1.8 km (1.1 mi)	1.7 km (1.1 mi)
Landmarks	Rose Hall Great House (1770)	Rose Hall Great House (1770)	Rose Hall Great House (1770)	Rose Hall Great House (1770)
Best suited for			Comfort-focused travelers	Sightseeing travelers

Guest score

Rose Hall

7/10

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

5.6/10

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.6/10

Seacastles Apartments

7.4/10

Rooms

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.7

The room was noted as clean and tidy.

Seacastles Apartments

7.2

The apartment was small but had everything we needed.

Cleanliness

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.2

The mention of leaving keys in doors raises safety concerns, reflecting negatively on the hotel's management.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

8.2

The reviews consistently mention that everything is clean and tidy.

Seacastles Apartments

6.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Location

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

7.2

Amazing location with beautiful mountain and ocean views, enhancing the overall appeal.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.8

Sea Castles is conveniently located about 15 minutes drive from MBJ Airport.

Service

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

6.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier, though service expectations were not highlighted.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

7.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.7

All the staff were very kind and accommodating.

Sleep & Noise

Rose Hall

—

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

—

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

—

Seacastles Apartments

—

Food & Breakfast

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

8.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

6.7

Great amenities like a pool and tennis courts, enhancing guest experience.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

6.2

No chairs by the pool side noted as a downside.

Seacastles Apartments

7.8

The kitchenette was well stocked; the pool was well maintained.

Value

Rose Hall

Not enough guest feedback

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

4.7

Standard quality for this hotel tier; specifics were not mentioned.

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

8.2

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Seacastles Apartments

7.7

We felt we got a good value for what we paid.

Landmarks

Rose Hall

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Takuma Boutique Hotel Rooms & Suites Jamaica

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Seacastles Exclusive Vacation Rentals

Rose Hall Great House (1770)

Seacastles Apartments

Rose Hall Great House (1770)