Our pick
English
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Cleanliness
9.2Negative sentiment due to inability to stay at the hotel and issues with payment.
Location
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier, but impacted by payment issues.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Palm-Eagle Beach, AW
★ 4-star10/101 reviews
Our pick
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
Palm-Eagle Beach, AW
★ 4-star9.5/10132 reviews
0.59 km (0.37 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Summerside 410.0
Bananas Apartments Adults Only9.3
Location
Summerside 410.0
Bananas Apartments Adults Only9.3
Food & Breakfast
Summerside 410.0
Bananas Apartments Adults Only9.3
Amenities & Facilities
Summerside 410.0
Bananas Apartments Adults Only9.3
Value
Summerside 410.0
Summerside 59.3
Bananas Apartments Adults Only amenity advantages
Non-smoking roomsLaundryFamily roomsSun loungers or beach chairs
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.0 km.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only: 0.59 km (0.37 mi)
Summerside 4: 2.6 km (1.6 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
10/10Summerside 4
9.8/10Summerside 5
9.5/10Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.5/10Rooms
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Summerside 5
9.3The accommodation matched the photos and was comfortable.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.3Guests describe the rooms as spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped.
Cleanliness
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
9.2Negative sentiment due to inability to stay at the hotel and issues with payment.
Summerside 5
8.9The review mentioned a slight issue with water hotness, indicating some upkeep needed.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.3Overall, several reviews mention the accommodation was clean and well-maintained.
Location
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier, but impacted by payment issues.
Summerside 5
9.9Not explicitly mentioned; assumed positive due to mention of excellent amenities.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.3Reviewers appreciate the great location for snorkeling and proximity to beaches.
Service
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier, but impacted by payment issues.
Summerside 5
9.9Overall positive sentiment; maintenance resolved issues promptly.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.8Many reviews highlight the welcoming and helpful nature of the hosts.
Sleep & Noise
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
—Summerside 4
—Summerside 5
—Bananas Apartments Adults Only
—Food & Breakfast
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Summerside 5
9.4Not mentioned; assumed positive due to overall satisfaction.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.3No specific input on food, but the overall amenities support a positive sentiment.
Amenities & Facilities
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Summerside 5
9.4The pool was excellent for post-beach relaxation.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.3Positive comments regarding the facilities, such as pool and decor.
Value
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
Not enough guest feedbackSummerside 4
10.0Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Summerside 5
9.3Not explicitly mentioned; inferred as satisfactory based on overall positive review.
Bananas Apartments Adults Only
9.8Reviewers feel they received good value for what they paid.
Landmarks
Catalina Residence Apt 3 - L.G. Smith Boulevard 546-J
SS AntillaSummerside 4
Palm Beach DiversSummerside 5
Palm Beach DiversBananas Apartments Adults Only
Shipwreck