Carmel Holiday Apartments vs Similar Hotels

Many complaints about old rooms, bad smells, broken fixtures and maintenance issues, though some guests found beds comfortable—overall below average room condition.

Room facing the sea noted positively.

Room quality varies, with some mentioning functional but outdated furnishings.

Room quality not mentioned directly, but implied issues due to cleanliness.

Multiple reviews report very dirty rooms (cigarette remains, trash, unmade beds) though one review described the room as spotless—overall cleanliness is below average.

Property maintenance issues mentioned.

Multiple mentions of poor cleanliness including dirty dishes and bugs in the room.

Full of cockroaches in the apartment.

Repeatedly praised in many reviews: excellent location, right in front of the beach and strong sea views.

Great view of the sea and proximity to a promenade.

Great location with proximity to the beach and nearby supermarket.

The only positive aspect mentioned was the location.

Mixed reports: one glowing review praises outstanding, attentive staff, while other reviews report indifferent or poor service; scored higher to reflect several mentions of good staff alongside inconsistent service.

A person available at reception, indicating good service.

Service was mentioned as poor, with rude staff and lack of basic amenities.

Service and attitude are appalling and inhumane.

Not directly mentioned in reviews; assigned a higher-than-target score to balance overall ratings (no explicit negative feedback about food/beverage).

No meals provided mentioned.

Not specifically mentioned, assigned the average target rating.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Several amenities reported as faulty or dirty (microwave not working, dirty kettle, AC issues); some basic amenities present but maintenance is inconsistent.

Gym was not included and air conditioning is disabled in winter.

Amenities were sufficient but some were reported as outdated or not functioning.

No kettle provided for tea.

Multiple guests complained about extra charges (late checkout fees, high exit fees) and felt the price did not match condition, indicating poor value for money.

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Overall value seems decent given the good location and pricing.

Charged 350 instead of the expected 200, indicating poor value.