Ellen Bay Inn vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Ellen Bay Cottages

Saint Philips, AG

★ 3-star9.1/10172 reviews

0.23 km (0.14 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

9.1

Rooms are described as big, comfortable, and equipped with good amenities.

Cleanliness

9.2

The place is very clean, which is positively noted in the reviews.

Location

9.2

The location is praised for its proximity to the sea and attractions.

Close alternatives

No close alternative was identified for this preference.

Hotels (2 selected)

Original hotel

Ellen Bay Inn

Saint Philips, AG

★ 3-star8.9/1094 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

Ellen Bay Cottages

Saint Philips, AG

★ 3-star9.1/10172 reviews

0.23 km (0.14 mi) from original

View hotel

Key differences

Value

Ellen Bay Cottages9.1

Ellen Bay Inn8.3

Ellen Bay Inn amenity advantages

Swimming poolRoom servicePets allowedBreakfast in the room

Detailed comparison

Category	Ellen Bay Inn	Ellen Bay Cottages
Guest score	8.9/10	9.1/10
Rooms	8.7 Rooms were noted for being comfortable and well-equipped.	9.1 Rooms are described as big, comfortable, and equipped with good amenities.
Cleanliness	8.7 Guests appreciated the cleanliness of the rooms, noting their comfort.	9.2 The place is very clean, which is positively noted in the reviews.
Location	9.2 The location is praised for being peaceful and accessible to beautiful beaches.	9.2 The location is praised for its proximity to the sea and attractions.
Service	9.4 Multiple reviews mentioned friendly and attentive staff, providing a positive service experience.	9.6 The hosts are described as very friendly and helpful, with great service.
Sleep & Noise	—	—
Food & Breakfast	9.0 Food quality received high marks, especially at the on-site restaurant.	8.7 No specific mentions, but overall dining options near by.
Amenities & Facilities	8.7 Amenities were adequate, with some mentions of restaurant facilities.	8.7 Good kitchen facilities and WiFi noted; amenities satisfactory.
Value	8.3 While some found it not value for money, overall opinions were generally positive.	9.1 Overall value is justified by the experience and amenities.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.23 km (0.14 mi)
Landmarks	Stingray City	Stingray City
Best suited for	Comfort-focused travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Ellen Bay Inn

8.9/10

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.1/10

Rooms

Ellen Bay Inn

8.7

Rooms were noted for being comfortable and well-equipped.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.1

Rooms are described as big, comfortable, and equipped with good amenities.

Cleanliness

Ellen Bay Inn

8.7

Guests appreciated the cleanliness of the rooms, noting their comfort.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.2

The place is very clean, which is positively noted in the reviews.

Location

Ellen Bay Inn

9.2

The location is praised for being peaceful and accessible to beautiful beaches.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.2

The location is praised for its proximity to the sea and attractions.

Service

Ellen Bay Inn

9.4

Multiple reviews mentioned friendly and attentive staff, providing a positive service experience.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.6

The hosts are described as very friendly and helpful, with great service.

Sleep & Noise

Ellen Bay Inn

—

Ellen Bay Cottages

—

Food & Breakfast

Ellen Bay Inn

9.0

Food quality received high marks, especially at the on-site restaurant.

Ellen Bay Cottages

8.7

No specific mentions, but overall dining options near by.

Amenities & Facilities

Ellen Bay Inn

8.7

Amenities were adequate, with some mentions of restaurant facilities.

Ellen Bay Cottages

8.7

Good kitchen facilities and WiFi noted; amenities satisfactory.

Value

Ellen Bay Inn

8.3

While some found it not value for money, overall opinions were generally positive.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.1

Overall value is justified by the experience and amenities.

Landmarks

Ellen Bay Inn

Stingray City

Ellen Bay Cottages

Stingray City

Detailed comparison

Category	Ellen Bay Inn	Ellen Bay Cottages
Guest score	8.9/10	9.1/10
Rooms	8.7 Rooms were noted for being comfortable and well-equipped.	9.1 Rooms are described as big, comfortable, and equipped with good amenities.
Cleanliness	8.7 Guests appreciated the cleanliness of the rooms, noting their comfort.	9.2 The place is very clean, which is positively noted in the reviews.
Location	9.2 The location is praised for being peaceful and accessible to beautiful beaches.	9.2 The location is praised for its proximity to the sea and attractions.
Service	9.4 Multiple reviews mentioned friendly and attentive staff, providing a positive service experience.	9.6 The hosts are described as very friendly and helpful, with great service.
Sleep & Noise	—	—
Food & Breakfast	9.0 Food quality received high marks, especially at the on-site restaurant.	8.7 No specific mentions, but overall dining options near by.
Amenities & Facilities	8.7 Amenities were adequate, with some mentions of restaurant facilities.	8.7 Good kitchen facilities and WiFi noted; amenities satisfactory.
Value	8.3 While some found it not value for money, overall opinions were generally positive.	9.1 Overall value is justified by the experience and amenities.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.23 km (0.14 mi)
Landmarks	Stingray City	Stingray City
Best suited for	Comfort-focused travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Ellen Bay Inn

8.9/10

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.1/10

Rooms

Ellen Bay Inn

8.7

Rooms were noted for being comfortable and well-equipped.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.1

Rooms are described as big, comfortable, and equipped with good amenities.

Cleanliness

Ellen Bay Inn

8.7

Guests appreciated the cleanliness of the rooms, noting their comfort.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.2

The place is very clean, which is positively noted in the reviews.

Location

Ellen Bay Inn

9.2

The location is praised for being peaceful and accessible to beautiful beaches.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.2

The location is praised for its proximity to the sea and attractions.

Service

Ellen Bay Inn

9.4

Multiple reviews mentioned friendly and attentive staff, providing a positive service experience.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.6

The hosts are described as very friendly and helpful, with great service.

Sleep & Noise

Ellen Bay Inn

—

Ellen Bay Cottages

—

Food & Breakfast

Ellen Bay Inn

9.0

Food quality received high marks, especially at the on-site restaurant.

Ellen Bay Cottages

8.7

No specific mentions, but overall dining options near by.

Amenities & Facilities

Ellen Bay Inn

8.7

Amenities were adequate, with some mentions of restaurant facilities.

Ellen Bay Cottages

8.7

Good kitchen facilities and WiFi noted; amenities satisfactory.

Value

Ellen Bay Inn

8.3

While some found it not value for money, overall opinions were generally positive.

Ellen Bay Cottages

9.1

Overall value is justified by the experience and amenities.

Landmarks

Ellen Bay Inn

Stingray City

Ellen Bay Cottages

Stingray City