Our pick
English
Excelsior vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Location
8.7Frequently noted as a strong point due to its central position.
Service
8.2Generally positive feedback on staff friendliness and helpfulness.
Food & Breakfast
7.2Breakfast and dining options received criticism, particularly regarding pricing and quality.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
Piombino, IT
★ 3-star9.6/100 reviews
0.08 km (0.05 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Excelsior8.3
Hotel Centrale7.2
Cleanliness
Excelsior8.2
Hotel Centrale6.7
Amenities & Facilities
Excelsior8.0
Hotel Centrale7.2
Value
Excelsior8.3
Hotel Centrale7.7
Hotel Centrale amenity advantages
24-hour front deskRoom serviceBusiness centerLaundryLuggage storage
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Excelsior
8.3/10Hotel Centrale
7.6/10APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
9.6/10B&B Regina Margherita
7.4/10Rooms
Excelsior
8.3Room quality is generally good, though complaints about noise and specific furniture were noted.
Hotel Centrale
7.2Comments indicate some rooms are dated but functional.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Cleanliness
Excelsior
8.2Cleanliness is mentioned in several reviews, highlighting the rooms' cleanliness, but noted issues with some amenities.
Hotel Centrale
6.7Mixed reviews regarding cleanliness with mentions of dustiness and poor maintenance.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Location
Excelsior
8.7Location is often highlighted as a strong point, being central and convenient.
Hotel Centrale
8.7Frequently noted as a strong point due to its central position.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Service
Excelsior
8.7Service was frequently praised across reviews for being attentive and polite.
Hotel Centrale
8.2Generally positive feedback on staff friendliness and helpfulness.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Sleep & Noise
Excelsior
—Hotel Centrale
—APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Food & Breakfast
Excelsior
7.7Food options received criticism regarding breakfast, impacting the overall perception.
Hotel Centrale
7.2Breakfast and dining options received criticism, particularly regarding pricing and quality.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Amenities & Facilities
Excelsior
8.0Several guests noted the lack of amenities, specifically breakfast options and refrigerator issues.
Hotel Centrale
7.2Some amenities are lacking or outdated, affecting overall satisfaction.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Value
Excelsior
8.3Value is discussed with mixed reviews, some feeling it was overpriced for certain amenities.
Hotel Centrale
7.7Value perception is mixed with some guests feeling prices are too high for the quality offered.
APPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
—B&B Regina Margherita
—Landmarks
Excelsior
Piazza Dante AlighieriHotel Centrale
Giardino di LeonardoAPPARTAMENTI TRA CIELO E MARE
Landmark data unavailableB&B Regina Margherita
Landmark data unavailable