Hotel New Otani Nagaoka vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

Nagaoka, JP

★ 2-star8/10102 reviews

0.12 km (0.07 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Rooms

8.1

Rooms are clean and well-maintained though a bit small.

Location

8.7

Convenient location with dining options nearby.

Value

8.6

Good value for what you get considering the location and cleanliness.

Close alternatives

No close alternative was identified for this preference.

Hotels (2 selected)

Original hotel

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

Nagaoka, JP

★ 4-star8.6/10307 reviews

View hotel

Our pick

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

Nagaoka, JP

★ 2-star8/10102 reviews

0.12 km (0.07 mi) from original

View hotel

Trade-offs

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Cleanliness8.2

Service9.0

Food & Breakfast8.8

Amenities & Facilities8.5

Key differences

Cleanliness

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka8.2

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station7.6

Service

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka9.0

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station8.1

Food & Breakfast

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka8.8

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station7.6

Amenities & Facilities

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka8.5

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station7.1

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka amenity advantages

WiFi availableNon-smoking roomsAir conditioningRestaurantLift / Elevator

Detailed comparison

Category	Hotel New Otani Nagaoka	Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station
Guest score	8.6/10	8/10
Rooms	8.4 Rooms are spacious but noted as a bit outdated.	8.1 Rooms are clean and well-maintained though a bit small.
Cleanliness	8.2 Some reviews mention outdated rooms and lingering smoke odor.	7.6 Some concerns about cleanliness in the bathroom and toilet seat.
Location	9.0 Multiple reviews pointed out the excellent and convenient location.	8.7 Convenient location with dining options nearby.
Service	9.0 Friendly staff and prompt responses were positively highlighted.	8.1 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Sleep & Noise	—	—
Food & Breakfast	8.8 The breakfast is frequently praised for its quality.	7.6 Limited dining options nearby if it rains but plenty of options overall.
Amenities & Facilities	8.5 Standard amenities were mentioned as satisfactory; some requests were not fulfilled.	7.1 No parking and limited amenities but acceptable for business stays.
Value	8.4 Good price-quality ratio, but some hiccups were mentioned with updates.	8.6 Good value for what you get considering the location and cleanliness.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.12 km (0.07 mi)
Landmarks	正三尺玉打揚筒	台町公園
Best suited for	Business travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.6/10

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8/10

Rooms

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.4

Rooms are spacious but noted as a bit outdated.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.1

Rooms are clean and well-maintained though a bit small.

Cleanliness

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.2

Some reviews mention outdated rooms and lingering smoke odor.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

7.6

Some concerns about cleanliness in the bathroom and toilet seat.

Location

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

9.0

Multiple reviews pointed out the excellent and convenient location.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.7

Convenient location with dining options nearby.

Service

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

9.0

Friendly staff and prompt responses were positively highlighted.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.1

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sleep & Noise

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

—

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

—

Food & Breakfast

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.8

The breakfast is frequently praised for its quality.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

7.6

Limited dining options nearby if it rains but plenty of options overall.

Amenities & Facilities

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.5

Standard amenities were mentioned as satisfactory; some requests were not fulfilled.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

7.1

No parking and limited amenities but acceptable for business stays.

Value

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.4

Good price-quality ratio, but some hiccups were mentioned with updates.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.6

Good value for what you get considering the location and cleanliness.

Landmarks

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

正三尺玉打揚筒

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

台町公園

Detailed comparison

Category	Hotel New Otani Nagaoka	Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station
Guest score	8.6/10	8/10
Rooms	8.4 Rooms are spacious but noted as a bit outdated.	8.1 Rooms are clean and well-maintained though a bit small.
Cleanliness	8.2 Some reviews mention outdated rooms and lingering smoke odor.	7.6 Some concerns about cleanliness in the bathroom and toilet seat.
Location	9.0 Multiple reviews pointed out the excellent and convenient location.	8.7 Convenient location with dining options nearby.
Service	9.0 Friendly staff and prompt responses were positively highlighted.	8.1 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Sleep & Noise	—	—
Food & Breakfast	8.8 The breakfast is frequently praised for its quality.	7.6 Limited dining options nearby if it rains but plenty of options overall.
Amenities & Facilities	8.5 Standard amenities were mentioned as satisfactory; some requests were not fulfilled.	7.1 No parking and limited amenities but acceptable for business stays.
Value	8.4 Good price-quality ratio, but some hiccups were mentioned with updates.	8.6 Good value for what you get considering the location and cleanliness.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.12 km (0.07 mi)
Landmarks	正三尺玉打揚筒	台町公園
Best suited for	Business travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.6/10

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8/10

Rooms

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.4

Rooms are spacious but noted as a bit outdated.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.1

Rooms are clean and well-maintained though a bit small.

Cleanliness

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.2

Some reviews mention outdated rooms and lingering smoke odor.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

7.6

Some concerns about cleanliness in the bathroom and toilet seat.

Location

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

9.0

Multiple reviews pointed out the excellent and convenient location.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.7

Convenient location with dining options nearby.

Service

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

9.0

Friendly staff and prompt responses were positively highlighted.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.1

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Sleep & Noise

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

—

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

—

Food & Breakfast

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.8

The breakfast is frequently praised for its quality.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

7.6

Limited dining options nearby if it rains but plenty of options overall.

Amenities & Facilities

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.5

Standard amenities were mentioned as satisfactory; some requests were not fulfilled.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

7.1

No parking and limited amenities but acceptable for business stays.

Value

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

8.4

Good price-quality ratio, but some hiccups were mentioned with updates.

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

8.6

Good value for what you get considering the location and cleanliness.

Landmarks

Hotel New Otani Nagaoka

正三尺玉打揚筒

Hotel Live Max Niigata Nagaoka Station

台町公園