Kudehya Guesthouse vs Similar Hotels

Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.

Search hotels

What matters most to you?

Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Best overall fit

Our pick

Waikiki Guest House

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star7.3/10115 reviews

0.04 km (0.03 mi) from original

View our pick

✓Why it stands out

Location

9.2

Strong positive: consistently praised as right on or steps from the beach with great views and convenient access to shops and local spots.

Service

8.4

Generally praised: multiple guests noted a friendly, helpful owner/management who assisted with favors and were available when needed.

Value

8.0

Positive value perception: multiple reviews explicitly state the place offers good value for the price and meets expectations.

Close alternatives

Very close alternative

Taino Cove

Better if you care more about Rooms, Cleanliness.

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Kudehya Guesthouse

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star8.8/104 reviews

View hotel

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star10/102 reviews

0.82 km (0.51 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Waikiki Guest House

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star7.3/10115 reviews

0.04 km (0.03 mi) from original

View hotel

Taino Cove

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star7.5/1033 reviews

0.25 km (0.15 mi) from original

View hotel

Trade-offs

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.

Taino Cove

May suit you better if you prioritize:

Rooms6.8

Cleanliness7.9

Key differences

Rooms

Taino Cove6.8

Waikiki Guest House6.0

Cleanliness

Taino Cove7.9

Waikiki Guest House7.0

Location

Waikiki Guest House9.2

Taino Cove8.4

Value

Waikiki Guest House8.0

Taino Cove7.3

Kudehya Guesthouse amenity advantages

Wheelchair accessible

Waikiki Guest House amenity advantages

24-hour front desk

Taino Cove amenity advantages

Non-smoking roomsAir conditioningSwimming poolSpa/wellness centerConcierge service

Distance from original

The compared hotels differ by 0.78 km.

Waikiki Guest House: 0.04 km (0.03 mi)

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage: 0.82 km (0.51 mi)

Detailed comparison

Category	Kudehya Guesthouse	Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage	Waikiki Guest House	Taino Cove
Guest score	8.8/10	10/10	7.3/10	7.5/10
Rooms	—	—	6.0 Several complaints: rooms described as basic/old, some lacked AC (fan only) and got very hot, mattresses/pillows often criticized and occasional maintenance issues reported.	6.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Cleanliness	—	—	7.0 Mixed reports: some guests described the property as very clean, but others mentioned insects in rooms and litter/overgrown areas near the beach path, so overall cleanliness is average-to-good.	7.9 The review mentions the hotel is clean.
Location	—	—	9.2 Strong positive: consistently praised as right on or steps from the beach with great views and convenient access to shops and local spots.	8.4 Beautiful setting with breathtaking scenic views.
Service	—	—	8.4 Generally praised: multiple guests noted a friendly, helpful owner/management who assisted with favors and were available when needed.	8.4 The review highlights friendly and helpful staff.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	—	—	7.3 Not mentioned in reviews: assigned target overall rating of 7.3.	6.9 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	—	—	6.5 Limited amenities noted: mosquito nets available in some rooms but reports of no hot water, no AC in some units and otherwise minimal facilities.	6.9 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value	—	—	8.0 Positive value perception: multiple reviews explicitly state the place offers good value for the price and meets expectations.	7.3 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.82 km (0.51 mi)	0.04 km (0.03 mi)	0.25 km (0.15 mi)
Landmarks	Cashaw Park Estate	Cashaw Park Estate	Cashaw Park Estate	Cashaw Park Estate
Best suited for	Quiet leisure travelers		Quiet leisure travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Kudehya Guesthouse

8.8/10

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

10/10

Waikiki Guest House

7.3/10

Taino Cove

7.5/10

Rooms

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

6.0

Several complaints: rooms described as basic/old, some lacked AC (fan only) and got very hot, mattresses/pillows often criticized and occasional maintenance issues reported.

Taino Cove

6.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Cleanliness

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

7.0

Mixed reports: some guests described the property as very clean, but others mentioned insects in rooms and litter/overgrown areas near the beach path, so overall cleanliness is average-to-good.

Taino Cove

7.9

The review mentions the hotel is clean.

Location

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

9.2

Strong positive: consistently praised as right on or steps from the beach with great views and convenient access to shops and local spots.

Taino Cove

8.4

Beautiful setting with breathtaking scenic views.

Service

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

8.4

Generally praised: multiple guests noted a friendly, helpful owner/management who assisted with favors and were available when needed.

Taino Cove

8.4

The review highlights friendly and helpful staff.

Sleep & Noise

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

—

Taino Cove

—

Food & Breakfast

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

7.3

Not mentioned in reviews: assigned target overall rating of 7.3.

Taino Cove

6.9

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

6.5

Limited amenities noted: mosquito nets available in some rooms but reports of no hot water, no AC in some units and otherwise minimal facilities.

Taino Cove

6.9

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Value

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

8.0

Positive value perception: multiple reviews explicitly state the place offers good value for the price and meets expectations.

Taino Cove

7.3

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Landmarks

Kudehya Guesthouse

Cashaw Park Estate

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

Cashaw Park Estate

Waikiki Guest House

Cashaw Park Estate

Taino Cove

Cashaw Park Estate

Hotels (4 selected)

Original hotel

Kudehya Guesthouse

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star8.8/104 reviews

View hotel

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star10/102 reviews

0.82 km (0.51 mi) from original

View hotel

Our pick

Waikiki Guest House

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star7.3/10115 reviews

0.04 km (0.03 mi) from original

View hotel

Taino Cove

Treasure Beach, JM

★ 3-star7.5/1033 reviews

0.25 km (0.15 mi) from original

View hotel

Detailed comparison

Category	Kudehya Guesthouse	Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage	Waikiki Guest House	Taino Cove
Guest score	8.8/10	10/10	7.3/10	7.5/10
Rooms	—	—	6.0 Several complaints: rooms described as basic/old, some lacked AC (fan only) and got very hot, mattresses/pillows often criticized and occasional maintenance issues reported.	6.8 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Cleanliness	—	—	7.0 Mixed reports: some guests described the property as very clean, but others mentioned insects in rooms and litter/overgrown areas near the beach path, so overall cleanliness is average-to-good.	7.9 The review mentions the hotel is clean.
Location	—	—	9.2 Strong positive: consistently praised as right on or steps from the beach with great views and convenient access to shops and local spots.	8.4 Beautiful setting with breathtaking scenic views.
Service	—	—	8.4 Generally praised: multiple guests noted a friendly, helpful owner/management who assisted with favors and were available when needed.	8.4 The review highlights friendly and helpful staff.
Sleep & Noise	—	—	—	—
Food & Breakfast	—	—	7.3 Not mentioned in reviews: assigned target overall rating of 7.3.	6.9 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities	—	—	6.5 Limited amenities noted: mosquito nets available in some rooms but reports of no hot water, no AC in some units and otherwise minimal facilities.	6.9 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value	—	—	8.0 Positive value perception: multiple reviews explicitly state the place offers good value for the price and meets expectations.	7.3 Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Distance from original	Original hotel	0.82 km (0.51 mi)	0.04 km (0.03 mi)	0.25 km (0.15 mi)
Landmarks	Cashaw Park Estate	Cashaw Park Estate	Cashaw Park Estate	Cashaw Park Estate
Best suited for	Quiet leisure travelers		Quiet leisure travelers	Quiet leisure travelers

Guest score

Kudehya Guesthouse

8.8/10

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

10/10

Waikiki Guest House

7.3/10

Taino Cove

7.5/10

Rooms

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

6.0

Several complaints: rooms described as basic/old, some lacked AC (fan only) and got very hot, mattresses/pillows often criticized and occasional maintenance issues reported.

Taino Cove

6.8

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Cleanliness

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

7.0

Mixed reports: some guests described the property as very clean, but others mentioned insects in rooms and litter/overgrown areas near the beach path, so overall cleanliness is average-to-good.

Taino Cove

7.9

The review mentions the hotel is clean.

Location

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

9.2

Strong positive: consistently praised as right on or steps from the beach with great views and convenient access to shops and local spots.

Taino Cove

8.4

Beautiful setting with breathtaking scenic views.

Service

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

8.4

Generally praised: multiple guests noted a friendly, helpful owner/management who assisted with favors and were available when needed.

Taino Cove

8.4

The review highlights friendly and helpful staff.

Sleep & Noise

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

—

Taino Cove

—

Food & Breakfast

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

7.3

Not mentioned in reviews: assigned target overall rating of 7.3.

Taino Cove

6.9

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Amenities & Facilities

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

6.5

Limited amenities noted: mosquito nets available in some rooms but reports of no hot water, no AC in some units and otherwise minimal facilities.

Taino Cove

6.9

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Value

Kudehya Guesthouse

—

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

—

Waikiki Guest House

8.0

Positive value perception: multiple reviews explicitly state the place offers good value for the price and meets expectations.

Taino Cove

7.3

Standard quality for this hotel tier.

Landmarks

Kudehya Guesthouse

Cashaw Park Estate

Sea Dragon Three Bedroom Cottage

Cashaw Park Estate

Waikiki Guest House

Cashaw Park Estate

Taino Cove

Cashaw Park Estate