
Spice Island Beach Resort
Saint Georgeʼs, GD
0.18 km (0.11 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Saint Georgeʼs, GD
0.18 km (0.11 mi) from original
Rooms
10.0Spacious and well-equipped rooms were available.
Cleanliness
10.0The hotel was clean and welcoming.
Location
10.0The location was perfect, with a beautiful public beach.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Saint Georgeʼs, GD
0.18 km (0.11 mi) from original

Saint Georgeʼs, GD
0.65 km (0.41 mi) from original

Saint Georgeʼs, GD
1.6 km (1.0 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.5 km.
Spice Island Beach Resort: 0.18 km (0.11 mi)
La Heliconia & Day Spa: 1.6 km (1.0 mi)
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
9.1/10Spice Island Beach Resort
10/10Kalinago Beach Resort
8.2/10La Heliconia & Day Spa
7.9/10Blue Horizons Garden Resort
8.4Some rooms were reported to not meet expectations.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0Spacious and well-equipped rooms were available.
Kalinago Beach Resort
6.6Reports of mismatched lamps and lack of hot water.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
7.4Mixed: some guests liked spacious rooms/apartments and comfortable beds; others reported run-down fixtures (rusty oven, broken shower tap) and firm beds, so slightly below target.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
9.4Very clean, as mentioned in multiple reviews.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0The hotel was clean and welcoming.
Kalinago Beach Resort
6.6Multiple mentions of dirty linen and unkempt rooms.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
6.5Mixed reports: some guests found rooms clean, but multiple reviews mention dirt, ants in breakfast, dirty doors, rusty oven, and unclean pool/bed sheets — overall below target.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
9.4Quiet and convenient location with positive feedback.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0The location was perfect, with a beautiful public beach.
Kalinago Beach Resort
10.0Perfect location, directly across from the beach.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
9.8Consistently praised for proximity to the airport and convenience to town/transport — one of the strongest positives across reviews.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
9.9Excellent service noted by multiple guests.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0The staff went above and beyond, and almost everyone was super friendly.
Kalinago Beach Resort
10.0Staff were described as exceptional and lovely.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
9.7Generally described as friendly and efficient (smooth check-in/out, helpful staff) in most reviews; a few isolated incidents (missed transfer, delayed fixes, lost camera) but majority feedback was positive, so score is high to reflect overall perceived reliability.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
—Spice Island Beach Resort
—Kalinago Beach Resort
—La Heliconia & Day Spa
—Blue Horizons Garden Resort
8.9Generally good food quality but some service issues noted.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0Buffet is limited and dinner was consistently underwhelming.
Kalinago Beach Resort
6.6Negative feedback on food quality.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
6.7Varied experiences: some mention very good/full breakfasts, others report minimal offerings, ants in hot water/coffee area, or restaurant closed — overall mixed-to-negative.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
8.9Pool and garden amenities were well appreciated.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0Generous mini bar and great spa treatments.
Kalinago Beach Resort
9.6Standard amenities, though improvement needed for rooms.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
8.3Pool and basic facilities are appreciated by many; however occasional complaints about pool cleanliness and limited evening services reduce the score slightly.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
8.4Some guests found the restaurant prices too high.
Spice Island Beach Resort
10.0Food was underwhelming for the price; better options are available elsewhere.
Kalinago Beach Resort
7.6Perceived as substandard and unacceptable due to several issues.
La Heliconia & Day Spa
6.2Several guests felt the price did not match quality (upgraded rooms still with faults, partial refunds, lost items) — perceived as weaker value.
Blue Horizons Garden Resort
Camerhogne ParkSpice Island Beach Resort
Camerhogne ParkKalinago Beach Resort
Quarantine Point ParkLa Heliconia & Day Spa
Conch Graveyard