L'Esquisse Hotel & Spa Colmar - MGallery Collection vs Similar Hotels

Spacious and well-kept rooms with good amenities noted positively.

Numerous complaints about rooms being small, old, and not as described.

Rooms described as beautiful, luxurious and comfortable with excellent bedding and well-appointed bathrooms; one guest noted a slightly worn sofa.

Rooms were mostly comfortable, with some criticism regarding bedding.

Concerns about bathroom cleanliness were raised; not meeting expectations for a 5-star hotel.

Multiple mentions of cleanliness issues; room with spider webs, old pillows, and complaints about dirt.

Rooms described as very clean and tidy by several guests, but some reports of stained hallway carpeting and a damaged sofa reduce the score slightly.

Most reviews mentioned cleanliness favorably, but some noted room temperature issues.

Great location close to the city center and Christmas markets.

Many reviewers praised the excellent location near tourist spots and markets.

Multiple guests call it the best/central location in town; extremely convenient for walking. Some guests noted difficulty accessing by car due to pedestrian zones and construction.

Frequently highlighted as a major positive across several reviews.

Generally good service noted, but some specific complaints about front desk and breakfast staff.

Staff is frequently described as very friendly and attentive.

Repeated praise for friendly, helpful and professional staff; reception assisted with luggage and provided clear communication, chef and restaurant service also highlighted.

Service was generally praised, although there were specific complaints about staff attitude.

Breakfast variety appreciated, but pricing concerns mentioned.

Breakfast quality received positive remarks across multiple reviews.

Breakfast repeatedly praised (delicious, abundant, served in attractive settings) and the restaurant/chef received multiple strong compliments.

Breakfast and food options received positive feedback.

Nice spa facilities and a great breakfast selection.

Some amenities were lacking such as inadequate toiletries and no minibar.

Strong amenities mentioned (air conditioning, on-site parking with reservation, dog-friendly policy, attractive hotel grounds and facilities).

Some amenities were satisfactory, but there were missing essentials in certain rooms.

High price-point raised concerns about value given the issues experienced.

Many felt the price was too high for the quality offered.

Standard quality for this hotel tier

Mixed reviews regarding value; some found it pricey compared to experience.