
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.3Rooms are described as spacious with beautiful details, though some mentions of missing amenities are noted.
Cleanliness
9.3No specific issues mentioned; overall quality appears acceptable.
Location
9.7Attractive setting with convenient access to the surrounding area.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Campbellton, CA
0.92 km (0.57 mi) from original


Campbellton, CA
1.6 km (0.98 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.1 km.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB: 0.92 km (0.57 mi)
Napier House: 2.0 km (1.3 mi)
Clarion Pointe
7.8/10Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
7.6/10Napier House
9.4/10Maison McKenzie House
8.6/10Clarion Pointe
6.8Mixed to negative: complaints about noisy thin walls, slamming corridor doors, noisy or ineffective air conditioning, small windows, low shower pressure and lack of elevator; some guests found rooms comfy and quiet.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
6.6Complaints about outdated decor, cold floors, and noise issues affected overall perception.
Napier House
9.3Rooms are described as spacious with beautiful details, though some mentions of missing amenities are noted.
Maison McKenzie House
8.3Some reviews noted that rooms were adequate but sometimes small.
Clarion Pointe
6.8Mixed reports: several guests praised that rooms were clean, but there are multiple complaints about carpet with food leftovers, hair and sand on beds, unpleasant room scent and instances of rooms 'not very well cleaned'.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
7.1The place was noted as clean, but some reviews indicated issues, including moldy smells.
Napier House
9.3No specific issues mentioned; overall quality appears acceptable.
Maison McKenzie House
8.7Reviews frequently mention cleanliness as a positive aspect of the stay.
Clarion Pointe
8.0Mostly convenient for road trips and as a gateway to the Gaspé Peninsula with nearby grocery and sports bar, though some guests criticized the town/area (outskirts, ‘dump’) and felt location was not ideal.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
9.1Positive remarks about the location being great for access and convenience.
Napier House
9.7Attractive setting with convenient access to the surrounding area.
Maison McKenzie House
8.6Many reviews highlight the convenient location near key attractions.
Clarion Pointe
9.5Generally very positive: staff repeatedly described as polite, helpful, warm and attentive; a few notes of unsatisfactory lobby/reception service but overall staff friendliness and helpfulness stood out.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
8.6Generally positive, with some mentions of courteous staff, although there were complaints about service availability.
Napier House
9.8Hosts received multiple positive mentions for attentiveness and friendliness.
Maison McKenzie House
9.0Michel's friendly and accommodating service received consistent praise.
Clarion Pointe
—Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
—Napier House
—Maison McKenzie House
—Clarion Pointe
8.0Varied breakfast experiences: several guests praised the breakfast (even 'exceptional'), while others complained about poor juice, odd-tasting tea or logistical issues with breakfast timing/availability.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
7.6Breakfast was positively noted, though some reviews indicated limited options.
Napier House
9.3Breakfast received high praise, indicating strong quality.
Maison McKenzie House
9.0Breakfast was widely praised with mentions of delicious homemade options.
Clarion Pointe
8.0Basic amenities available (breakfast, lobby drinks, AC, soap/shampoo dispensers) but some operational issues reported: empty dispensers, empty water/juice in lobby, noisy AC, and suggestions to upgrade coffee machine.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
7.6Not all amenities were up to modern standards; however, some positive mentions of the breakfast.
Napier House
8.8Some guests noted a desire for more amenities, though overall has been rated positively.
Maison McKenzie House
8.0Positive mentions of breakfast and atmosphere; minor complaints about lacking toiletries.
Clarion Pointe
7.5Mixed perception: some guests felt it was expensive for the quality, others found it adequate as a short rest stop; overall value is moderate given the pros and cons mentioned.
Super 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
7.1Several guests felt the quality did not justify the cost, pointing towards high prices for lower quality.
Napier House
9.3Overall experience aligns with high perceived value based on positive reviews.
Maison McKenzie House
8.5Overall value appeared good based on the positive experiences shared.
Clarion Pointe
Parc Sugarloaf ParkSuper 8 by Wyndham Campbellton NB
CrossNapier House
Riverside ParkMaison McKenzie House
Cross