Old Course Hotel vs Similar Hotels

This was AMAZING. The room was excellent.

Some rooms showing signs of wear and needing some TLC.

Rooms were described as comfortable but were noted to be a bit small.

Some reviews noted rooms were comfortable but small; improvements needed for larger guests.

Restaurant service was poor, affecting overall cleanliness perception.

The room was very clean and comfy.

The rooms were noted as clean, but some concerns about noise and the need for more towels were mentioned.

General sentiment was positive regarding cleanliness, with many reviews mentioning clean rooms.

Overlooking the golf course with great convenience.

GREAT location, walkable to the Old Course, with a lively pub downstairs.

Multiple reviews highlighted the excellent and convenient location, making it a clear pro.

Location is highlighted as fantastic, being close to major attractions and the Old Course.

Staff is awesome and concierge went above and beyond.

The staff were very accommodating and friendly, with excellent service.

Guests mentioned helpful staff and easy check-in/check-out process, contributing positively to the service rating.

Staff were described as friendly and professional in multiple reviews.

Food at the hotel was very good.

Breakfast was good and pub grub was enjoyable.

Breakfast was grab-and-go; could enhance the offering for a better rating.

Breakfast was noted as wonderful, with high praise for food quality.

Good amenities supporting a great stay; a golf course is a highlight.

Lack of tea making facilities noted as a negative.

Basic amenities were available, but some guests suggested more options for beverages.

Amenities were mentioned but could be more extensive; standard for this hotel tier.

Spend the money and enjoy St. Andrews properly.

Overall great experience and worth the stay.

Overall good value noted, but some aspects could be improved.

Many guests felt the experience justified the cost.