Our pick
Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
Sheffield, GB
★ 3-star8/10169 reviews
5.2 km (3.2 mi) from original
English
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Service
9.7The staff received multiple compliments for being friendly and helpful during the stay.
Food & Breakfast
8.2No specific sentiments about food were mentioned; standard for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
8.2Basic amenities like tea and coffee were provided, but some additional costs applied.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Sheffield, GB
★ 4-star9.6/105 reviews
2.3 km (1.4 mi) from original
Our pick
Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
Sheffield, GB
★ 3-star8/10169 reviews
5.2 km (3.2 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection8.2
Staindrop Hotel6.8
Cleanliness
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection7.7
Staindrop Hotel5.3
Location
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection9.7
Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M17.7
Service
Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M19.7
Staindrop Hotel8.3
Food & Breakfast
Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M18.2
Staindrop Hotel7.3
Amenities & Facilities
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection8.7
Staindrop Hotel6.8
Value
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection9.1
Staindrop Hotel7.8
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection amenity advantages
Concierge serviceMeeting rooms
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna amenity advantages
WiFi availableSwimming poolHot tub/Jacuzzi
Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1 amenity advantages
Electric car charging station
Staindrop Hotel amenity advantages
Wheelchair-accessible on-site restaurant
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 14.5 km.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna: 2.3 km (1.4 mi)
Staindrop Hotel: 16.8 km (10.4 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
8.8/10RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
9.6/10Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
8/10Staindrop Hotel
7.4/10Rooms
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
8.2Rooms were comfortable but needed maintenance.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
7.2Most rooms were described as decent, though one review pointed out significant issues.
Staindrop Hotel
6.8Spacious bedroom but had several maintenance issues.
Cleanliness
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
7.7Rooms were clean but not the best maintained and had small issues.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
6.7Several reviews highlighted unsanitary conditions, particularly in the ground floor room.
Staindrop Hotel
5.3Room needed a deep clean, especially the bathroom.
Location
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
9.7Brilliant location with amazing views.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
7.7Location requires some maneuvering to access, but is acceptable overall.
Staindrop Hotel
8.8Lovely location in a quiet village with easy access to the city.
Service
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
9.7Friendly service noted during wedding reception and overall positive experiences.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
9.7The staff received multiple compliments for being friendly and helpful during the stay.
Staindrop Hotel
8.3Service with a smile, but issues with staff availability noted.
Sleep & Noise
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
—RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
—Days Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
—Staindrop Hotel
—Food & Breakfast
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
8.2Limited breakfast choices and slow service.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
8.2No specific sentiments about food were mentioned; standard for this hotel tier.
Staindrop Hotel
7.3Breakfast was freshly prepared, but dining options were not tested.
Amenities & Facilities
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
8.7Facilities were great during the wedding reception.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
8.2Basic amenities like tea and coffee were provided, but some additional costs applied.
Staindrop Hotel
6.8Some amenities like toiletries and hairdryer were lacking.
Value
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
9.1Standard quality for this hotel tier.
RentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Not enough guest feedbackDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
8.2Guests felt the price was reasonable for the quality received.
Staindrop Hotel
7.8Considering issues, value reflects average pricing.
Landmarks
Aston Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection
Aston ParkRentMySpaHome with Swimming Pool Hottub and Sauna
Burgoyne ParkDays Inn by Wyndham Sheffield M1
Spens FieldStaindrop Hotel
Cart Drive Open Space