
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.8Overall decent room quality noted, though some issues with noise and light were mentioned.
Cleanliness
7.8Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness, including a shower drain not working well and bedding smelling of urine.
Location
10.0Positive feedback regarding the location, especially the beautiful view at night.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Rustenburg, ZA
2.0 km (1.3 mi) from original

Rustenburg, ZA
3.8 km (2.4 mi) from original

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 7.8 km.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge: 2.0 km (1.3 mi)
LilyPark Lodge: 9.8 km (6.1 mi)
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
8.3/10Manor Hills Guest Lodge
8.3/10BON Hotel Rustenburg
7.7/10LilyPark Lodge
9/10ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
7.5Some rooms had maintenance issues and concerns about allocated rooms.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
7.8Rooms are clean and well-equipped (fridge, microwave, coffee machine) for many guests, but some issues were reported: twin beds uncomfortable for couples, spotlights shining into bedrooms, aircon problems and chilly floors in some units.
BON Hotel Rustenburg
6.9Issues with rooms not being ready and general discomfort mentioned.
LilyPark Lodge
8.8Overall decent room quality noted, though some issues with noise and light were mentioned.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
7.0Several reviews mentioned poor cleanliness and maintenance issues.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
7.6Mixed reports: several guests mention very clean rooms, but at least one guest reported hair on the pillow and debris under beds, indicating inconsistent housekeeping.
BON Hotel Rustenburg
5.9Multiple complaints regarding cleanliness with mentions of dirty blankets and unmade rooms.
LilyPark Lodge
7.8Several reviews mention issues with cleanliness, including a shower drain not working well and bedding smelling of urine.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
9.0Guests appreciated the beautiful location and surroundings.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
8.8Generally safe and peaceful (gate closed at night, tranquil grounds) and suitable for families, though one guest experienced significant external noise from a nearby shebeen.
BON Hotel Rustenburg
8.9The location is praised for its peace and beautiful surroundings.
LilyPark Lodge
10.0Positive feedback regarding the location, especially the beautiful view at night.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
9.3Overall, many reviews praised staff as friendly and attentive despite some negative mentions.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
8.8Mostly praised—multiple comments about very friendly and helpful staff and good on-site service. There is one serious management complaint about a refund handling issue, but overall staff interactions are positive.
BON Hotel Rustenburg
8.9Generally positive comments about staff being friendly and accommodating.
LilyPark Lodge
9.3Mixed sentiments; however, some reviews highlight friendly staff and good hospitality.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
—Manor Hills Guest Lodge
—BON Hotel Rustenburg
—LilyPark Lodge
—ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
8.5Food was well-received, though some issues with temperature were reported.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
7.9Food receives positive mentions (excellent restaurant, good breakfast) but there are recurring issues with timing/availability (restaurant closed at arrival, buffet times, limited breakfast options) and one report of disappointing room service.
BON Hotel Rustenburg
8.4Some positive comments on food quality, but also criticisms regarding breakfast experience.
LilyPark Lodge
7.8The lack of breakfast and the closure of dining options were noted negatively by guests.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
8.5Facilities described positively, but some reviews noted unexpected problems.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
8.7Strong amenities: multiple pools, on-site restaurant, safe parking, good grounds and wildlife. Some operational/wayfinding issues noted (pool signposting, spotlights, occasional closures).
BON Hotel Rustenburg
6.9Concerns about missing amenities such as microwaves and hairdryers.
LilyPark Lodge
8.8Amenities were generally sufficient, but the lack of entertainment (few TV channels) was a downside.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
7.9Concerns were raised regarding the value due to recent service issues.
Manor Hills Guest Lodge
8.3Not explicitly discussed in reviews; assigned the target overall rating as a neutral baseline.
BON Hotel Rustenburg
6.9Guests felt they did not receive value for their money due to several complaints.
LilyPark Lodge
9.8Most guests felt the stay was worth the cost, with specific mention of cleanliness and quietness.
ANEW Resort Hunters Rest Rustenburg
No landmark signals returnedManor Hills Guest Lodge
No landmark signals returnedBON Hotel Rustenburg
Elephant SculptureLilyPark Lodge
Paul Bodenstein Voëltjie Park