Astir Of Naxos vs Similar Hotels

Rooms reported as a little dated, and some guests mentioned old beds.

Several guests report very small, cramped rooms and an uncomfortable 120cm bed; noise from neighbors also mentioned. A few guests praised the room appearance, but room size and bed comfort are recurring negatives.

Generally very good: spacious, well decorated rooms with kitchenette, good air-conditioning and comfortable beds; some rooms can be small for 4 people, basement rooms may have odor issues and some bathroom doors lack full privacy.

The hotel was spotlessly clean, indicating high standards of cleanliness.

Generally reported as good (multiple guests explicitly praised cleanliness), but there are isolated issues: pool described as dirty by some and one guest noted housekeeping only occurs if a button is activated — inconsistent room servicing.

Mixed reports: several guests praised a clean pool and rooms, but others noted the pool appeared unclean at times and a basement room had a musty/sewer-like smell; occasional housekeeping noise also affected perceived cleanliness/rest.

The hotel is in a fantastic position, very close to the beach and main town.

Consistently excellent: many guests mention convenient location near the beach, old town and port; described as ideally situated and quiet despite central position.

Excellent location: within walking distance of Naxos town, port and beach; close to restaurants and a convenient spot for island navigation.

Evagelia and her family were very welcoming and helpful, significantly enhancing the service experience.

Strongly positive overall: numerous comments praise friendly, helpful and fun reception staff. Some operational lapses noted (taxi delay, unclear housekeeping instructions), but staff attitude and helpfulness are repeatedly highlighted.

Strongly positive: staff repeatedly described as friendly, helpful and accommodating (welcome drink, shuttle/port help, owner assisting with drop-offs); quick problem resolution when issues arose.

Breakfast received mixed reviews with mentions of being basic and repetitive.

Generally positive but mixed: several guests described breakfasts as delicious or 'super', while others found breakfast basic and not up to 4‑star expectations; one guest noted extra charges for a child's breakfast.

Breakfast rated average-to-good by several guests; some praised it while others suggested higher quality or greater variety (e.g., proper scrambled eggs).

Beautiful resort with a highly praised pool area.

Mixed: pool and hot tub repeatedly criticized as much smaller than pictured, sometimes cold or poorly maintained; beach services expensive and Wi‑Fi unreliable. Some guests still enjoyed the pool when not crowded, so amenities are usable but inconsistent.

Strong amenities: pleasant pool (including toddler pool), pool facilities/showers, kitchenette in rooms, airport shuttle and on-site car rental access; downside includes spotty WiFi outside pool area.

Good value considering the location and service provided.

Multiple comments indicate the hotel feels overpriced for the standard delivered (small rooms, limited amenities, extra charges for child breakfast and beach loungers), leading to a below‑average value perception.

Fair value: many guests found the service and location good for the price, but extra transport costs to the main strip and average breakfast reduced perceived value for some families.