
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
10.0Guests booked the suite master and reported perfect rooms, comfortable beds, great decoration and amenities (hidro, view, etc.).
Cleanliness
10.0Multiple reviews highlight rooms and common areas as 'muito limpo' and praise the fresh scent and overall high cleanliness.
Location
10.0Praised as 'pertinho da praia', with wonderful sea views and easy parking; described as excellent location near beaches.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.


Ilhabela, BR
0.34 km (0.21 mi) from original


Ilhabela, BR
2.7 km (1.7 mi) from original
The compared hotels differ by 2.4 km.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel: 0.34 km (0.21 mi)
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela: 2.7 km (1.7 mi)
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
8.6/10VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
9.1/10Santomar Guest House
9.9/10Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
8.5/10VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
7.8Some rooms were reported as dark or lacking sufficient amenities; a few guests noted issues with showers.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
8.4Rooms described as comfortable but with some issues regarding aging furniture and noise.
Santomar Guest House
10.0Guests booked the suite master and reported perfect rooms, comfortable beds, great decoration and amenities (hidro, view, etc.).
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
7.9Some issues with noise and comfort; air conditioning had a buzzing noise.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
7.8Multiple guests reported cleanliness issues, such as moldy rooms.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
8.5Several reviews mention cleanliness issues, such as maintenance needs in bathrooms and a lack of deep cleaning.
Santomar Guest House
10.0Multiple reviews highlight rooms and common areas as 'muito limpo' and praise the fresh scent and overall high cleanliness.
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
8.0The bathroom was reported dirty and some towels were torn.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
8.8The location was frequently praised for being close to beaches, but noted as somewhat distant from the center.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
9.0Location praised for ambiance and accessibility, despite some concerns about beach access.
Santomar Guest House
10.0Praised as 'pertinho da praia', with wonderful sea views and easy parking; described as excellent location near beaches.
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
9.0Great location close to many attractions, though not directly on the beach.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
9.3Most reviews mentioned attentive and friendly staff, but there were delays in service.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
10.0Staff are frequently described as friendly, helpful, and attentive.
Santomar Guest House
10.0Owners Edson and Fábia are repeatedly described as friendly, attentive and providing excellent reception; electronic access also simplifies check-in/check-out.
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
9.4Staff were attentive and responsive to issues raised.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
—VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
—Santomar Guest House
—Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
—VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
9.3The breakfast received high praise for quality and variety, contributing positively to the overall experience.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
9.5Breakfast consistently mentioned as excellent, though some minor suggestions for improvement noted.
Santomar Guest House
10.0Complimentary coffee sachets and a courtesy bottle of wine were appreciated; easy access to drinks via a 24hr fridge.
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
7.5Breakfast options were limited and lacked variety.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
8.3Amenities like the pool and breakfast were generally well-received, despite some complaints about the bathrooms.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
8.5Amenities such as the pool and breakfast are noted positively, but some facilities are outdated.
Santomar Guest House
10.0Good in-room amenities noted (linen, shampoo, soaps, bath salts, coffee sachets, courtesy wine) plus 24hr fridge for drinks and a pleasant deck/molhado area; minor note about no stove.
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
8.4Amenities generally okay, with a nice pool but some room comfort issues.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
8.8Guests felt the hotel provided good value for the rate, despite some complaints.
VELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
9.4Guests feel they received good value for the price, especially with the breakfast quality.
Santomar Guest House
9.2Overall very positive experience but some guests felt the cost is a bit high given no daily room service or linen change and the automatic check-in model.
Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
8.9The stay is considered good value, though some feel improvements could be made.
VELINN Pousada Canoa Ilhabela
Santuario EcológicoVELINN Feiticeira Praia Hotel
Praia de feiticeiraSantomar Guest House
Praia de feiticeiraHotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela
Praia de feiticeira