Our pick
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
Brixham, GB
★ 4-star9.5/1012 reviews
3.2 km (2.0 mi) from original
English
The Station Guest House vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Beautiful house with high-quality furnishings and presentation; everything provided was of high quality.
Cleanliness
10.0Everything was really clean and well presented according to the review.
Location
8.0Super location with beautiful views of Brixham bay, but access is hampered by many/steep steps down to the bay.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
Brixham, GB
★ 4-star9.5/1012 reviews
3.2 km (2.0 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham10.0
The Railway Inn7.9
Cleanliness
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham10.0
The Railway Inn7.4
Service
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham9.5
The Railway Inn8.9
Food & Breakfast
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham9.5
The Railway Inn8.4
Amenities & Facilities
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham10.0
The Railway Inn8.4
Value
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham9.5
The Railway Inn8.4
The Railway Inn amenity advantages
Beach
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham amenity advantages
Electric vehicle charging station
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 3.2 km.
The Railway Inn: 0.03 km (0.02 mi)
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham: 3.2 km (2.0 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
The Station Guest House
9.6/10The Melville
9.4/10The Railway Inn
8.2/10The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5/10Rooms
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
7.9Rooms were described as clean and comfortable, but some appeared tired.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
10.0Beautiful house with high-quality furnishings and presentation; everything provided was of high quality.
Cleanliness
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
7.4Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues and a 'bit grubby' feel.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
10.0Everything was really clean and well presented according to the review.
Location
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
7.9Noted as convenient but some mentioned it wasn't ideal.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
8.0Super location with beautiful views of Brixham bay, but access is hampered by many/steep steps down to the bay.
Service
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
8.9Numerous mentions of friendly, helpful, and efficient staff.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5Nice welcome pack and provisions indicate attentive, thoughtful service.
Sleep & Noise
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
—The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
—Food & Breakfast
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
8.4Excellent breakfast and evening meals mentioned positively.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier
Amenities & Facilities
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
8.4Good selection and quality of amenities offered.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
10.0Everything you need was provided and of high quality (well-equipped).
Value
The Station Guest House
—The Melville
—The Railway Inn
8.4Good value according to several reviews that highlighted the overall experience.
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier
Landmarks
The Station Guest House
Landmark data unavailableThe Melville
Landmark data unavailableThe Railway Inn
Churston Go-KartsThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
William Prince of Orange