
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
9.3Spacious well appointed apartment.
Cleanliness
9.8The whole house was very clean and white bedding, comfort.
Location
9.8The sea view was amazing and the location was close to amenities.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




Margate, ZA
0.47 km (0.29 mi) from original
Margate Beach Lodge
7.2/10Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
8.9/10Rondevoux 17
9.4/10First Group Margate Sands
8.1/10Margate Beach Lodge
6.6Issues with rooms, small size, and inadequate maintenance.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
8.9Rooms were spacious and well-maintained, with lovely views.
Rondevoux 17
9.3Spacious well appointed apartment.
First Group Margate Sands
6.8Mixed: some rooms have great views and well-equipped kitchens, but multiple reports of broken aircon/TV, crusted oven, flickering lights, uncomfortable furniture and signs of being run-down lower this score.
Margate Beach Lodge
6.1Multiple mentions of cleanliness problems and a dirty kitchen.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
8.9The rooms were described as very clean and neat.
Rondevoux 17
9.8The whole house was very clean and white bedding, comfort.
First Group Margate Sands
6.5Mixed reports: some guests praised cleanliness and daily servicing, but multiple reviews report roaches/cockroaches and inconsistent housekeeping attention, so overall cleanliness is below expectation.
Margate Beach Lodge
8.6Good location mentioned multiple times.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
9.4The place is beautiful and quiet, ideal for rest.
Rondevoux 17
9.8The sea view was amazing and the location was close to amenities.
First Group Margate Sands
10.0Consistently praised: excellent location with great views, close walking distance to the beach and nearby restaurants — frequently cited as a primary strength.
Margate Beach Lodge
8.1Pleasant and helpful staff noted in several reviews.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
9.4Staff were friendly and accommodating, providing positive encouragement.
Rondevoux 17
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
First Group Margate Sands
9.8Generally strong: many guests reported friendly, welcoming staff and smooth check-in; a few mentions of unapproachable or unhappy housekeeping staff and slow follow-up on issues, but overall service is a notable positive.
Margate Beach Lodge
—Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
—Rondevoux 17
—First Group Margate Sands
—Margate Beach Lodge
7.1Mixed reviews on breakfast quality.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
7.9Breakfast quality was not commented upon, but the welcome was friendly.
Rondevoux 17
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
First Group Margate Sands
9.1No strong on-site F&B offering reported; however guests noted easy access to nearby restaurants (didn't have to drive), so while hotel F&B is limited, dining options due to location are good.
Margate Beach Lodge
7.1Inconsistent amenities like Wi-Fi and TV not functioning.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
8.9Facilities like the pool and parking space were appreciated.
Rondevoux 17
8.8A lack of DSTV for sports enjoyment was mentioned.
First Group Margate Sands
5.8Significant negative sentiment: repeated false-advertising complaints (heated pool not heated, game room/trampoline/shopping centre missing or nonfunctional) make amenities a weak point.
Margate Beach Lodge
6.5Basic accommodation deemed overpriced.
Ingwe Manor Guesthouse
8.4Good for the price considering the aspects mentioned.
Rondevoux 17
9.3The venue was neat and stylish, providing good value.
First Group Margate Sands
7.0Mixed value: some standard offerings (daily towels, cleaned apartments) but false advertising, extra unexpected charges (e.g., second car fee) and missing facilities reduce perceived value.
Margate Beach Lodge
No landmark signals returnedIngwe Manor Guesthouse
No landmark signals returnedRondevoux 17
No landmark signals returnedFirst Group Margate Sands
No landmark signals returned