Our pick
English
Fay Guest House vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.2Generally acceptable, but some rooms were described as small.
Location
9.3Great location near Rick's Café and accessible to the beach.
Service
9.2Overall positive feedback about staff being helpful and friendly.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Cleanliness
Stoney Gate Cottages8.5
Bak A Yaad7.7
Location
Bak A Yaad9.3
Stoney Gate Cottages8.5
Fay Guest House amenity advantages
24-hour front deskSpa/wellness centerFitness facilities
Bak A Yaad amenity advantages
Swimming poolWheelchair accessibleElectric vehicle charging station
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Fay Guest House
8.6/10Stoney Gate Cottages
8.6/10Bak A Yaad
8.6/10Coral Cove Cottage
8.5/10Rooms
Fay Guest House
8.5Big room as mentioned in the review.
Stoney Gate Cottages
8.5Cottage was everything we required for our stay.
Bak A Yaad
8.2Generally acceptable, but some rooms were described as small.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackCleanliness
Fay Guest House
8.0The shower had issues as mentioned in the review.
Stoney Gate Cottages
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bak A Yaad
7.7Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly with bathrooms and the pool.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackLocation
Fay Guest House
9.1Great location with shared taxis available nearby.
Stoney Gate Cottages
8.5Only a short drive to the 7 mile.
Bak A Yaad
9.3Great location near Rick's Café and accessible to the beach.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackService
Fay Guest House
9.0Faye is described as a great host, contributing positively to service.
Stoney Gate Cottages
9.0Lawrence is a beautiful soul and his assistant is fabulous. Very accommodating.
Bak A Yaad
9.2Overall positive feedback about staff being helpful and friendly.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackSleep & Noise
Fay Guest House
—Stoney Gate Cottages
—Bak A Yaad
—Coral Cove Cottage
—Food & Breakfast
Fay Guest House
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Stoney Gate Cottages
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bak A Yaad
8.7No specific mentions, rated based on standard offerings in similar hotels.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackAmenities & Facilities
Fay Guest House
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Stoney Gate Cottages
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bak A Yaad
8.2Some amenities, like the pool and kitchen, received positive mentions, but cleanliness concerns exist.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackValue
Fay Guest House
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Stoney Gate Cottages
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Bak A Yaad
8.7Affordable pricing for the amenities provided, despite some deterioration.
Coral Cove Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackLandmarks
Fay Guest House
Rick's CafeStoney Gate Cottages
Rick's CafeBak A Yaad
Rick's CafeCoral Cove Cottage
Rick's Cafe