Our pick
Indigo Beach Resort
Black River, JM
★ 3-star7.2/1047 reviews
2.7 km (1.7 mi) from original
English
Deano's Cottages vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
7.0Rooms need renovation and were described as having issues, like broken amenities.
Cleanliness
5.5Multiple complaints about cleanliness issues and mosquitoes in the room.
Location
9.4The property is on a beautiful beach, highly praised by several reviewers.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
Black River, JM
★ 0-star7/101 reviews
2.6 km (1.6 mi) from original
Key differences
Deano's Cottages amenity advantages
Concierge serviceWheelchair accessibleBreakfast available (surcharge)Meeting rooms
Indigo Beach Resort amenity advantages
Room serviceLuggage storageGuest education on local ecosystems and culture
Beachscape At Black River Zermatt amenity advantages
WiFi available
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Deano's Cottages
6.8/10Indigo Beach Resort
7.2/10Magic Moments JA
10/10Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
7/10Rooms
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
7.0Rooms need renovation and were described as having issues, like broken amenities.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Cleanliness
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
5.5Multiple complaints about cleanliness issues and mosquitoes in the room.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Location
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
9.4The property is on a beautiful beach, highly praised by several reviewers.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Service
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
8.4Staff was described as friendly and helpful, though there were some service delays.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Sleep & Noise
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
—Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Food & Breakfast
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
5.5Restaurant closed and service delays for breakfast.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Amenities & Facilities
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
6.5Limited amenities, including closed restaurant and high prices on-site.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Value
Deano's Cottages
—Indigo Beach Resort
7.0Concerns about value due to service and amenities not aligning with expectations.
Magic Moments JA
—Beachscape At Black River Zermatt
—Landmarks
Deano's Cottages
J. Charles Swaby's Black River SafariIndigo Beach Resort
J. Charles Swaby's Black River SafariMagic Moments JA
J. Charles Swaby's Black River SafariBeachscape At Black River Zermatt
J. Charles Swaby's Black River Safari