Our pick
English
St John's B and B vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.9Guests consistently praised the comfort and quality of the rooms.
Location
9.5Most reviews describe the location positively, noting beautiful views and a peaceful environment.
Value
9.4Overall value is viewed positively with good experiences mentioned.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Blackbrink cottage9.9
Tatlers Guest House9.1
Cleanliness
The Castle Walk9.7
Tatlers Guest House8.2
Location
Tatlers Guest House9.7
The Castle Walk9.2
Service
St John's B and B10.0
Blackbrink cottage9.4
Food & Breakfast
Blackbrink cottage10.0
The Castle Walk8.7
Amenities & Facilities
Blackbrink cottage9.9
Tatlers Guest House8.7
Value
St John's B and B9.7
Tatlers Guest House8.6
The Castle Walk amenity advantages
Air conditioning
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 12.5 km.
Blackbrink cottage: 2.6 km (1.6 mi)
The Castle Walk: 15.1 km (9.4 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
St John's B and B
9.6/10Blackbrink cottage
9.5/10Tatlers Guest House
9.1/10The Castle Walk
9.4/10Rooms
St John's B and B
9.7Rooms were reported as immaculate and well-maintained.
Blackbrink cottage
9.9Guests consistently praised the comfort and quality of the rooms.
Tatlers Guest House
9.1General satisfaction with room comfort and facilities, despite some noise issues.
The Castle Walk
9.7Super comfortable bed and well-equipped accommodations.
Cleanliness
St John's B and B
9.3Spotlessly clean as mentioned in multiple reviews.
Blackbrink cottage
8.5Some reviews indicate the place is nice and clean, but there was a mention of a rundown farmhouse.
Tatlers Guest House
8.2Several mentions of cleanliness issues, particularly with dirty carpets and sewer gas.
The Castle Walk
9.7Everything was perfect and there were no complaints about cleanliness.
Location
St John's B and B
9.3Ideal for touring the midlands, though some reviews noted it was somewhat off the beaten path.
Blackbrink cottage
9.5Most reviews describe the location positively, noting beautiful views and a peaceful environment.
Tatlers Guest House
9.7Multiple reviews highlighted the convenience and centrality of the location.
The Castle Walk
9.2Ideal location short walk into town, close to amenities.
Service
St John's B and B
10.0Marie is highlighted as an exceptional and warm hostess.
Blackbrink cottage
9.4While there was a negative experience with one staff member, many reviews praise the hosts for their helpfulness.
Tatlers Guest House
9.7Most reviews complimented the helpfulness of the staff and easy check-in process.
The Castle Walk
9.7The owners were incredibly kind and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
St John's B and B
—Blackbrink cottage
—Tatlers Guest House
—The Castle Walk
—Food & Breakfast
St John's B and B
9.8Breakfasts were often praised as amazing and abundant.
Blackbrink cottage
10.0Breakfast received numerous compliments and was a highlight of many stays.
Tatlers Guest House
9.2Positive feedback on the breakfast provided by a nearby cafe.
The Castle Walk
8.7Provisions like milk, eggs, yogurt, and coffee provided.
Amenities & Facilities
St John's B and B
9.2Thoughtful amenities in rooms and a comfortable atmosphere.
Blackbrink cottage
9.9Amenities were generally well reviewed, with specific praises for the breakfast.
Tatlers Guest House
8.7Some amenities were mentioned, but there's room for improvement, especially with breakfast options.
The Castle Walk
9.7Equipped with everything you could possibly need.
Value
St John's B and B
9.7Overall sentiment suggests high value for the experience provided.
Blackbrink cottage
9.4Overall value is viewed positively with good experiences mentioned.
Tatlers Guest House
8.6Indications that pricing may be high without included amenities like breakfast.
The Castle Walk
9.2Great value for a convenient and functional stay.
Landmarks
St John's B and B
The VillageBlackbrink cottage
The VillageTatlers Guest House
Loughlenane ParkThe Castle Walk
Loughlenane Park