Our pick
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
Brixham, GB
★ 4-star9.5/1012 reviews
1.1 km (0.67 mi) from original
English
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Beautiful house with high-quality furnishings and presentation; everything provided was of high quality.
Cleanliness
10.0Everything was really clean and well presented according to the review.
Service
9.5Nice welcome pack and provisions indicate attentive, thoughtful service.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
Brixham, GB
★ 4-star9.5/1012 reviews
1.1 km (0.67 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham10.0
Harbour View8.3
Cleanliness
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham10.0
Harbour View8.5
Location
Harbour View8.8
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham8.0
Service
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham9.5
Harbour View8.9
Food & Breakfast
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham9.5
Harbour View8.7
Amenities & Facilities
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham10.0
Harbour View8.6
Value
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham9.5
Harbour View8.4
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool amenity advantages
Swimming poolPrivate beach area
The Captain's Cottage, Brixham amenity advantages
Family roomsElectric vehicle charging station
Harbour View amenity advantages
Pets allowed
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
8.6/10The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5/10Harbour View
8.6/10The Melville
9.4/10Rooms
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
10.0Beautiful house with high-quality furnishings and presentation; everything provided was of high quality.
Harbour View
8.3Mixed reviews; some rooms small and issues with en-suite facilities noted.
The Melville
—Cleanliness
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
10.0Everything was really clean and well presented according to the review.
Harbour View
8.5Rooms and areas mentioned as clean, but minor issues with maintenance were noted.
The Melville
—Location
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
8.0Super location with beautiful views of Brixham bay, but access is hampered by many/steep steps down to the bay.
Harbour View
8.8Great location near the town center with beautiful views.
The Melville
—Service
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5Nice welcome pack and provisions indicate attentive, thoughtful service.
Harbour View
8.9Staff consistently described as friendly and helpful, providing great service.
The Melville
—Sleep & Noise
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
—The Captain's Cottage, Brixham
—Harbour View
—The Melville
—Food & Breakfast
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier
Harbour View
8.7Breakfast was praised as fantastic and enjoyable.
The Melville
—Amenities & Facilities
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
10.0Everything you need was provided and of high quality (well-equipped).
Harbour View
8.6Standard amenities for the hotel category, including breakfast and parking.
The Melville
—Value
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Not enough guest feedbackThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
9.5Standard quality for this hotel tier
Harbour View
8.4Good value considering the overall experience, though some room issues noted.
The Melville
—Landmarks
Osprey 3, The Cove - Sea view - On site pool
Landmark data unavailableThe Captain's Cottage, Brixham
William Prince of OrangeHarbour View
Man and BoyThe Melville
Landmark data unavailable