Our pick
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
Port Edward, ZA
★ 4-star9.5/1095 reviews
3.2 km (2.0 mi) from original
English
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.5The unit was described as beautiful, clean, and comfortable.
Location
9.5The views and peaceful environment were highly praised.
Service
10.0The owner and cleaner were described as very kind and accommodating.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
Port Edward, ZA
★ 4-star9.4/1070 reviews
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
Port Edward, ZA
★ 4-star9.5/1060 reviews
2.0 km (1.2 mi) from original
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
Port Edward, ZA
★ 3-star7.7/101,212 reviews
2.1 km (1.3 mi) from original
Our pick
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
Port Edward, ZA
★ 4-star9.5/1095 reviews
3.2 km (2.0 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"9.8
The Estuary Hotel & Spa7.1
Cleanliness
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"9.3
The Estuary Hotel & Spa6.7
Location
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms9.7
The Estuary Hotel & Spa8.7
Service
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas10.0
The Estuary Hotel & Spa8.6
Food & Breakfast
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas9.5
The Estuary Hotel & Spa8.2
Amenities & Facilities
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms9.8
The Estuary Hotel & Spa7.7
Value
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas9.5
The Estuary Hotel & Spa7.1
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms amenity advantages
Luggage storagePets allowed
The Estuary Hotel & Spa amenity advantages
RestaurantRoom serviceMeeting/banquet facilitiesBreakfast in the room
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.2 km.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide": 2.0 km (1.2 mi)
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas: 3.2 km (2.0 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.4/10The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.5/10The Estuary Hotel & Spa
7.7/10Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
9.5/10Rooms
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.2Rooms were comfortable and well-maintained.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.8The Villa was very spacious and comfortable.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
7.1Some comments indicated that rooms were old or not as expected, but others found them spacious and with great views.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
9.5The unit was described as beautiful, clean, and comfortable.
Cleanliness
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.3Overall sentiment was positive, noting the house was really neat and clean.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.3The Villa was very spacious and clean, very clean, and peaceful.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
6.7The reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness, including broken showers and not-so-clean rooms.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
8.5Some concerns about hygiene related to towel placement.
Location
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.7Location was favorable, offering a great retreat in the wild coast.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.3Very beautiful view of the ocean and river, amazing views.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
8.7Many reviews praised the great location and stunning views, enhancing the overall appeal.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
9.5The views and peaceful environment were highly praised.
Service
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.7Guests appreciated the exceptional service provided by the host.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.8The instructions were user friendly and security was accommodating.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
8.6The staff were frequently described as friendly and attentive, contributing positively to the experience.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
10.0The owner and cleaner were described as very kind and accommodating.
Sleep & Noise
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
—The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
—The Estuary Hotel & Spa
—Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
—Food & Breakfast
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
8.8Not specifically mentioned, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
8.2Food received positive feedback, especially breakfast, although some complaints about service timing were noted.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
9.5Not specifically mentioned but assumed standard for accommodations.
Amenities & Facilities
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.8Guests were impressed with the amenities provided, including kitchenware and laundry facilities.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.3A lot of activities were available to do.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
7.7Amenities like the spa and food service were highlighted positively, but some areas need upgrading.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
9.5Top appliances and excellent furnishings noted.
Value
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
9.2Guests felt it was a great value for the quality and services offered.
The Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
9.3Overall excellence, good comfort for price.
The Estuary Hotel & Spa
7.1The hotel is considered overpriced for the amenities and quality offered, as noted in several reviews.
Privately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
9.5Considered excellent value and worth the stay.
Landmarks
Big Fish Seaside Cottage, Sleeps 10 Guests in 5 Bedrooms
No landmark signals returnedThe Estuary Country Estate, Villa "Once Upon A Tide"
No landmark signals returnedThe Estuary Hotel & Spa
No landmark signals returnedPrivately Owned Apartment at Ocean View Villas
No landmark signals returned