Our pick
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
Kingston, JM
★ 0-star9.2/1014 reviews
1.6 km (0.98 mi) from original
English
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.1The apartment was very beautiful.
Cleanliness
9.2The apartment was very nice and clean.
Location
9.5Great location with a good view from the balcony.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
Kingston, JM
★ 0-star7.2/1016 reviews
0.37 km (0.23 mi) from original
Our pick
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
Kingston, JM
★ 0-star9.2/1014 reviews
1.6 km (0.98 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool9.1
Shirley Retreat7.9
Cleanliness
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool9.2
Shirley Retreat8.0
Location
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool9.5
Shirley Retreat8.5
Service
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool9.7
Shirley Retreat8.4
Food & Breakfast
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool9.2
Shirley Retreat7.5
Amenities & Facilities
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool8.7
Shirley Retreat8.0
Value
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool8.9
Shirley Retreat7.9
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym amenity advantages
Concierge service
Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6 amenity advantages
Accessible train station shuttle
Shirley Retreat amenity advantages
WiFi availableFree WiFiNon-smoking rooms24-hour front deskLaundry
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.2 km.
Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6: 0.37 km (0.23 mi)
Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool: 1.6 km (0.98 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
8/10Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
7.2/10Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
9.2/10Shirley Retreat
8/10Rooms
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
9.1The apartment was very beautiful.
Shirley Retreat
7.9Room quality is generally mentioned as comfortable.
Cleanliness
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
9.2The apartment was very nice and clean.
Shirley Retreat
8.0The hotel is described as very clean in multiple reviews.
Location
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
9.5Great location with a good view from the balcony.
Shirley Retreat
8.5The location is noted as convenient, near attractions like the museum.
Service
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
9.7The owner was very nice and helpful during check-in.
Shirley Retreat
8.4The staff is mentioned multiple times as friendly and accommodating.
Sleep & Noise
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
—Shirley Retreat
—Food & Breakfast
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Shirley Retreat
7.5Breakfast options were noted as basic; there was some mention of pre-notification for breakfast.
Amenities & Facilities
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
8.7Key card was required to power electronics.
Shirley Retreat
8.0Basic amenities are available, although some limitations in food options were noted.
Value
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
—Finest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
—Lush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
8.9A bit small for the price.
Shirley Retreat
7.9Value for money is considered acceptable based on overall sentiments.
Landmarks
Luxe City Oasis 2BR with Rooftop Pool and Gym
Waterloo Road Community ParkFinest Accommodation Marley Manor Apt # 513 Ground Floor 6 Marley Rd Kgn 6
Devon HouseLush Penthouse Escape with Rooftop Pool
Seaview ParkShirley Retreat
Devon House