
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Rooms
8.0Rooms are described as cosy, quiet and comfortable but there are recurring negatives: small room/bathroom size, some storage limitations, lack of air conditioning and stairs/no elevator which lowered room comfort for some guests.
Cleanliness
9.5Multiple reviews explicitly praise cleanliness — 'super clean', 'very clean', 'limpieza exquisita' — indicating consistently high housekeeping standards.
Location
9.5Many guests highlight the central, convenient location (walking distance to city centre, near Luas and bus stops, St Stephen’s Green area), often cited as a major positive.
No close alternative was identified for this preference.




What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 1.1 km.
Phoenix Park Hotel: 1.0 km (0.62 mi)
Kilronan House: 2.0 km (1.3 mi)
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
8/10Kilronan House
9/10Phoenix Park Hotel
8/10Handel's Hotel
8.1/10Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
7.3Issues with old mattress and general maintenance needs in the flat.
Kilronan House
8.0Rooms are described as cosy, quiet and comfortable but there are recurring negatives: small room/bathroom size, some storage limitations, lack of air conditioning and stairs/no elevator which lowered room comfort for some guests.
Phoenix Park Hotel
7.5Overall room quality was good, but issues such as cold rooms and hard-to-regulate showers impacted the score.
Handel's Hotel
7.1Some rooms clean and modern, though noise and temperature control issues raised.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
6.8Multiple mentions of cleanliness issues, including spider webs and mold in bathrooms.
Kilronan House
9.5Multiple reviews explicitly praise cleanliness — 'super clean', 'very clean', 'limpieza exquisita' — indicating consistently high housekeeping standards.
Phoenix Park Hotel
8.1Reviews frequently mention that the hotel was clean, although some reviews noted it felt dated, which slightly lowers this score.
Handel's Hotel
7.7Some issues with cleanliness noted, particularly in bathrooms and room furnishings.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
9.3Good location, close to Tram line and only 4 minutes from Guinness Storehouse.
Kilronan House
9.5Many guests highlight the central, convenient location (walking distance to city centre, near Luas and bus stops, St Stephen’s Green area), often cited as a major positive.
Phoenix Park Hotel
9.1The location is praised as excellent, particularly for its proximity to transportation and local attractions.
Handel's Hotel
9.2Great location highlighted across several reviews.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
8.8Clear communication with the landlord and included taxi transfer were positives.
Kilronan House
9.5Staff repeatedly described as friendly, helpful and efficient (assistance with carplay, responsive front desk), indicating excellent service levels.
Phoenix Park Hotel
8.6Staff were consistently described as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Handel's Hotel
9.2Overall friendly and accommodating service noted, though some reception issues reported.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
—Kilronan House
—Phoenix Park Hotel
—Handel's Hotel
—Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
8.8No specific mentions; assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Kilronan House
9.5Breakfast is consistently praised across languages for quality, variety and service ('excellent', 'very good', 'great choices'), making F&B a clear strength.
Phoenix Park Hotel
7.1Limited breakfast options mentioned by guests indicated room for improvement in food offerings.
Handel's Hotel
7.7Breakfast variety and quality were criticized.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
8.3Lack of a dishwasher and functioning hot water system, impacting convenience.
Kilronan House
7.5Mixed notes: helpful amenities like reliable WiFi and daily bottled water, but notable negatives such as unusable/limited parking, no air conditioning in some rooms, and missing toiletries/tissues that reduce the amenities score.
Phoenix Park Hotel
7.1Some amenities were lacking, such as insufficient facilities and no charging ports, affecting the overall impression.
Handel's Hotel
8.2Amenities generally satisfactory; minor issues with breakfast variety and bathroom fixtures.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
6.8Considered overpriced for the quality and upkeep of the flat.
Kilronan House
9.0Value is not directly discussed in most reviews; overall positive impressions and strong praise for breakfast/service/location suggest fair/good value for the stay.
Phoenix Park Hotel
8.5The hotel provides good value considering location and cleanliness, though some rooms are dated.
Handel's Hotel
7.6Good value mentioned, but some guests felt the service didn't match price.
Spacious Two bedroom City apartment Newport St Dublin 8
Guinness StorehouseKilronan House
The BirdsPhoenix Park Hotel
To JennyHandel's Hotel
Wood Quay