Our pick
Apartment Joanna
Rodney Bay Village, LC
★ 4-star9/1059 reviews
1.7 km (1.1 mi) from original
English
A-List Villas vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.3The apartment itself was nice and well appreciated.
Cleanliness
8.8The review suggests some issues with the nearby area rather than the apartment itself, thus a good score.
Service
9.8The hosts were very kind and went beyond expectations.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Rodney Bay Village, LC
★ 3-star8.8/106 reviews
0.57 km (0.36 mi) from original
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View
Rodney Bay Village, LC
★ 4-star7.9/10139 reviews
1.2 km (0.77 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Apartment Joanna9.3
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View7.0
Cleanliness
Apartment Joanna8.8
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View8.0
Location
A-List Villas8.8
Apartment Joanna7.8
Service
Apartment Joanna9.8
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View8.5
Food & Breakfast
A-List Villas8.8
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View7.0
Amenities & Facilities
Apartment Joanna9.3
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View7.5
Value
Apartment Joanna9.3
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View8.5
Cleopatra Villas - Sea View amenity advantages
Luggage storageAirport shuttle
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.1 km.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2: 0.57 km (0.36 mi)
Apartment Joanna: 1.7 km (1.1 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
A-List Villas
8.7/10Apartment Joanna
9/10Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
8.8/10Cleopatra Villas - Sea View
7.9/10Rooms
A-List Villas
8.5Enough rooms to fit everyone inside.
Apartment Joanna
9.3The apartment itself was nice and well appreciated.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
7.0The comfort level was poor due to the hard mattress, and the A/C was not functioning well.
Cleanliness
A-List Villas
8.1The place does need some maintenance and updating.
Apartment Joanna
8.8The review suggests some issues with the nearby area rather than the apartment itself, thus a good score.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
8.0The accommodation was very clean and spacious.
Location
A-List Villas
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Apartment Joanna
7.8Rodney Bay is described as a building site with safety concerns at night.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
8.6Great location: short walks to the beach and supermarket.
Service
A-List Villas
9.1The staff were great and happy to help.
Apartment Joanna
9.8The hosts were very kind and went beyond expectations.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
8.5The owners were very accommodating, especially Claudia who was very welcoming.
Sleep & Noise
A-List Villas
—Apartment Joanna
—Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
—Cleopatra Villas - Sea View
—Food & Breakfast
A-List Villas
8.8Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Apartment Joanna
8.8Not specifically mentioned, assigned standard quality.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
7.0Limited references to food and beverage; standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
A-List Villas
9.1A nice pool for everyone to share as a big group, excellent use of the barbecue.
Apartment Joanna
9.3The lovely pool was a positive feature.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
7.5Decent kitchen facilities but some amenities were lacking such as hairdryers.
Value
A-List Villas
8.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Apartment Joanna
9.3Implied good value given the overall positive sentiments.
Chalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Not enough guest feedbackCleopatra Villas - Sea View
8.5Excellent value for money in a paradise location.
Landmarks
A-List Villas
Ignatius York Felicien ParkApartment Joanna
WWII Old U.S. Military PillarsChalet Belizomi Tropical Villas No #2
Ignatius York Felicien ParkCleopatra Villas - Sea View
WWII Old U.S. Military Pillars