Our pick
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
Shanghai, CN
★ 4-star8.9/101,842 reviews
2.3 km (1.4 mi) from original
English
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Cleanliness
8.2Cleanliness and daily housekeeping were noted positively.
Location
9.7The hotel is in an excellent location near the subway and amenities.
Service
9.2Staff were described as friendly and accommodating.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
Shanghai, CN
★ 4-star8/101,110 reviews
1.6 km (0.96 mi) from original
Our pick
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
Shanghai, CN
★ 4-star8.9/101,842 reviews
2.3 km (1.4 mi) from original
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
Shanghai, CN
★ 4-star8.6/10371 reviews
2.3 km (1.4 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang9.6
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG7.3
Cleanliness
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai8.2
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG6.5
Location
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai9.7
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG9.0
Service
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang9.6
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG8.6
Food & Breakfast
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai8.7
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang7.1
Amenities & Facilities
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang9.6
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG7.5
Value
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang9.6
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG8.5
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessibleAirport shuttleElectric vehicle charging station
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista amenity advantages
Swimming poolSpa/wellness centerSauna
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 0.78 km.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG: 1.6 km (0.96 mi)
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai: 2.3 km (1.4 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
9/10Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
8/10Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
8.9/10Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
8.6/10Rooms
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
9.6Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
7.3Generally reasonable rooms with a large bathroom, but issues reported such as a slipping shower head and noisy/ineffective AC in hot weather.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
8.7Room quality was generally good, with some concerns about layout.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
7.8Variable comments on room quality; some rooms are dated, and others felt comfortable.
Cleanliness
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
7.6The cleanliness is noted as lacking, with hair and debris left on the floor.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
6.5Guests report inconsistent housekeeping (not always vacuumed, occasional dust on floor); towels and trash sometimes changed irregularly.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
8.2Cleanliness and daily housekeeping were noted positively.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
7.9Mixed reviews regarding cleanliness, with some mentioning smell and old conditions.
Location
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
9.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
9.0Very convenient — close to Longde/metro (about 600m), riverfront, safe and good for walks; easy access to airport/Imago Plaza.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
9.7The hotel is in an excellent location near the subway and amenities.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
9.4Frequent mentions of excellent location close to metro and activities.
Service
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
9.6Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
8.6Mostly praised as friendly, helpful and professional; staff resolved room incidents quickly. One reviewer noted very poor staff, indicating some variability.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
9.2Staff were described as friendly and accommodating.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
9.3Positive mentions of friendly and competent staff throughout the reviews.
Sleep & Noise
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
—Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
—Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
—Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
—Food & Breakfast
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
7.1Breakfast service noted as overcrowded and lacking food availability.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
8.5Breakfast buffet positively mentioned (bread, pastries, eggs, sausages, fruit, etc.); breakfast quality cited as a plus.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
8.7Breakfast described as varied and enjoyable.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
8.4Breakfast and dining options received mixed reviews on variety and quality.
Amenities & Facilities
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
9.6Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
7.5Includes daily bottled water and shuttle service; lacks a fridge in rooms and vending machine interfaces may be only in Chinese.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
8.7Had necessary amenities but some complaints regarding paid laundry.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
8.3Amenities include gym, pool, and restaurant, with some issues like jacuzzi not working.
Value
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
9.6Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
8.5Described as a good budget hotel for the price and location — generally considered reasonable value.
Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
8.7Overall perceived as good value for the price paid.
Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
8.8Generally good value, especially for those attending events nearby.
Landmarks
Hilton Garden Inn Shanghai Caoyang
百禧公园Holiday Inn Express Shanghai Putuo by IHG
曹家渡绿岛Modena by Fraser Putuo Shanghai
管弄公园Holiday Inn Shanghai Vista
东海园旅游咨询服务中心