
Piesang Valley Lodge
Plettenberg Bay, ZA
12.4 km (7.7 mi) from original
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence

Plettenberg Bay, ZA
12.4 km (7.7 mi) from original
Rooms
9.7Initial room was small and musty, but later rooms met guests' expectations.
Cleanliness
9.2Some issues mentioned with towels and need for more maintenance, particularly in bathrooms.
Location
10.0Described as quiet with a nice view, contributing positively to the overall stay.


Plettenberg Bay, ZA
12.4 km (7.7 mi) from original

Plettenberg Bay, ZA
8.3 km (5.2 mi) from original

What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 4.1 km.
Emily Moon River Lodge: 8.3 km (5.2 mi)
Piesang Valley Lodge: 12.4 km (7.7 mi)
Bella Manga Country Escape
9.5/10Piesang Valley Lodge
9.6/10Emily Moon River Lodge
9.5/10The Joneses
9.5/10Bella Manga Country Escape
8.8Generally positive sentiments, but one review mentioned rooms could be better maintained.
Piesang Valley Lodge
9.7Initial room was small and musty, but later rooms met guests' expectations.
Emily Moon River Lodge
9.6Spacious and well-appointed rooms, though some need TLC.
The Joneses
9.3Positive mentions of spacious and well-equipped apartments indicate strong room quality.
Bella Manga Country Escape
8.8Some guests mentioned cleanliness issues with the floors in one review.
Piesang Valley Lodge
9.2Some issues mentioned with towels and need for more maintenance, particularly in bathrooms.
Emily Moon River Lodge
8.1Swimming pool not very cleaned; bat infestation was a concern in one room.
The Joneses
9.3Generally positive sentiment regarding cleanliness, specific comments in reviews indicate well-maintained facilities.
Bella Manga Country Escape
9.8The location is described as peaceful and unique, perfect for a getaway.
Piesang Valley Lodge
10.0Described as quiet with a nice view, contributing positively to the overall stay.
Emily Moon River Lodge
10.0Well located, with beautiful views and surroundings.
The Joneses
9.8Many reviews appreciate the location for its proximity to attractions and peaceful surroundings.
Bella Manga Country Escape
10.0Guests praised the staff as friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Piesang Valley Lodge
10.0Guests praised the friendly and helpful service provided by the owner, John.
Emily Moon River Lodge
10.0Friendly and helpful staff throughout the stay.
The Joneses
9.8Multiple reviews highlight exceptional service, with hosts described as very friendly and accommodating.
Bella Manga Country Escape
—Piesang Valley Lodge
—Emily Moon River Lodge
—The Joneses
—Bella Manga Country Escape
9.8Positive remarks about the breakfast and snacks available on-site.
Piesang Valley Lodge
9.2Breakfast quality noted as below expectation for the price.
Emily Moon River Lodge
9.1Food quality varied, with some meals not up to standard.
The Joneses
9.3Comments on good food quality, though no specific review on food and beverage was noted.
Bella Manga Country Escape
9.8Amenities such as kitchen facilities and fireplace were appreciated.
Piesang Valley Lodge
9.2Some amenities noted to be in need of replacement, impacting overall experience.
Emily Moon River Lodge
9.6Good amenities but limited pool seating.
The Joneses
9.3Amenities noted such as pools and equipped kitchens received positive mentions.
Bella Manga Country Escape
9.3Positive feedback on value, though one guest had concerns regarding room amenities.
Piesang Valley Lodge
9.7Guests felt the price didn't fully align with breakfast quality and internet service.
Emily Moon River Lodge
9.6The accommodation and scenery justify the price overall.
The Joneses
9.3Guests feel that their experience was worth the cost, though not directly mentioned, indicated by overall satisfaction.
Bella Manga Country Escape
No landmark signals returnedPiesang Valley Lodge
Signal HillEmily Moon River Lodge
Malcolm Solomon SculptureThe Joneses
Timber Store