Our pick
9 Stoney Way Cottage
Underberg, ZA
★ 4-star9.6/10114 reviews
2.6 km (1.6 mi) from original
English
Tumble In vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.3Rooms were described as cozy and comfortable, although one mention of a small shower was noted.
Cleanliness
9.6Overall cleanliness appeared satisfactory with multiple reviewers praising the cleanliness of the cottage.
Location
9.8Many reviews mentioned the cottage's excellent location for exploring the area.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
Underberg, ZA
★ 0-star8.4/100 reviews
1.1 km (0.72 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
9 Stoney Way Cottage9.3
Malachite Manor8.3
Cleanliness
9 Stoney Way Cottage9.6
Tumble In8.8
Location
9 Stoney Way Cottage9.8
Tumble In9.1
Service
9 Stoney Way Cottage10.0
Tumble In9.2
Amenities & Facilities
9 Stoney Way Cottage9.8
Malachite Manor8.3
Value
9 Stoney Way Cottage9.3
Tumble In8.6
Tumble In amenity advantages
Family rooms
9 Stoney Way Cottage amenity advantages
Swimming pool
Sani Window B&B and Self catering amenity advantages
Wheelchair accessible
Malachite Manor amenity advantages
Restaurant
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 5.1 km.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering: 1.1 km (0.72 mi)
Malachite Manor: 6.2 km (3.9 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Tumble In
8.9/109 Stoney Way Cottage
9.6/10Sani Window B&B and Self catering
8.4/10Malachite Manor
9/10Rooms
Tumble In
8.9Rooms are spacious, comfortable, and tastefully decorated.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
9.3Rooms were described as cozy and comfortable, although one mention of a small shower was noted.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
8.3The rooms are comfortable but could benefit from additional amenities.
Cleanliness
Tumble In
8.8Reviews generally praised cleanliness, noting spacious and clean rooms.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
9.6Overall cleanliness appeared satisfactory with multiple reviewers praising the cleanliness of the cottage.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
9.3D'un confort et d'une propreté impeccables dans un cadre magnifique.
Location
Tumble In
9.1Location is convenient, near the main road and amenities.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
9.8Many reviews mentioned the cottage's excellent location for exploring the area.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
9.3Absolutely stunning location, beautiful setting.
Service
Tumble In
9.2Hosts were described as welcoming and efficient, with smooth check-in and check-out.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
10.0Reviewers consistently noted the attentive and thoughtful service of the hosts.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
9.3The staff are very friendly, polite, and helpful.
Sleep & Noise
Tumble In
—9 Stoney Way Cottage
—Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
—Food & Breakfast
Tumble In
9.2Breakfast received high praise, and special touches were highlighted.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
9.2Availability of coffee, tea, and honesty bar positively noted, enhancing the guest experience.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
9.3Wonderful staff, delicious breakfast and dinner.
Amenities & Facilities
Tumble In
8.4Some amenities were criticized, such as slow WiFi and missing kitchen towels.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
9.8The cottage was well-equipped with various amenities that enhanced the stay.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
8.3Basic amenities were available but some guests suggested more could be offered.
Value
Tumble In
8.6Guests felt the quality justified the price, although some minor improvements were suggested.
9 Stoney Way Cottage
9.3Reviews indicated a perception of good value considering the overall experience.
Sani Window B&B and Self catering
—Malachite Manor
9.3Overall good value for the experience and services.
Landmarks
Tumble In
No landmark signals returned9 Stoney Way Cottage
No landmark signals returnedSani Window B&B and Self catering
Landmark data unavailableMalachite Manor
No landmark signals returned