Macdonald Forest Hills Resort vs Similar Hotels

Reviews noted that rooms were dated and showing wear.

Frequently described as dated/tired: old-fashioned decor, worn mattresses, needs refurbishment; some rooms spacious and comfortable but others had noise or layout issues.

Several reviews mentioned signs of wear and tear, indicating cleanliness might be an issue.

Mixed but leaning negative: multiple reports of poor cleanliness (urine splashes, hair, unpleasant odour, dusty room) though some guests described rooms as clean and tidy.

Guests highlighted the fantastic location as a major pro.

Consistently strong: riverside/beautiful setting, excellent for Rob Roy Way and scenic views; good parking. Minor issue noted with unlit pathway to town.

Many reviews praised the staff for being friendly and helpful.

Generally praised: staff repeatedly described as friendly, welcoming and helpful. A few reports of disorganisation and one instance of poor front-desk handling (extra charge incident).

Limited menu options were noted, with some suggestions for improvement.

Breakfast widely praised (buffet, hearty choices); food generally good though a few guests found evening meals basic and one report of an unclean shower hose (mould).

Facilities like the gym, swimming pool, and sauna received positive mentions.

Good basic amenities: buffet breakfast, bar/restaurant, ample parking and well-kept grounds. Coach-party entertainment is a feature that some guests found undesirable.

Some comments indicated that prices were a bit high for the quality offered.

Mixed: several guests felt the hotel was overpriced for its condition (compared to expectations), while others found it acceptable for a stopover.