Our pick
The Old Manse Pickering
Pickering, GB
★ 4-star9.3/10615 reviews
1.4 km (0.87 mi) from original
English
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035 vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.1Rooms described as comfortable and well-appointed.
Cleanliness
9.2Numerous mentions of clean rooms and exceptionally clean accommodations.
Location
9.2Great location noted by multiple guests.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Best Western Forest and Vale Hotel
Pickering, GB
★ 3-star9/10623 reviews
1.5 km (0.94 mi) from original
Our pick
The Old Manse Pickering
Pickering, GB
★ 4-star9.3/10615 reviews
1.4 km (0.87 mi) from original
Key differences
Service
The Old Manse Pickering9.6
The White Swan Inn9.1
Food & Breakfast
The Old Manse Pickering9.7
The White Swan Inn8.6
Amenities & Facilities
The Old Manse Pickering9.2
Best Western Forest and Vale Hotel8.6
Value
The Old Manse Pickering9.1
Best Western Forest and Vale Hotel8.0
Best Western Forest and Vale Hotel amenity advantages
LaundryMeeting/banquet facilities
The Old Manse Pickering amenity advantages
Air conditioning
Detailed comparison
Guest score
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
8.6/10Best Western Forest and Vale Hotel
9/10The White Swan Inn
9/10The Old Manse Pickering
9.3/10Rooms
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
9.0Rooms are spacious, well-appointed, and comfortable.
The White Swan Inn
9.1The room was perfect and very comfortable.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.1Rooms described as comfortable and well-appointed.
Cleanliness
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
9.1The hotel was described as lovely and clean.
The White Swan Inn
9.1The room and ensuite were well proportioned, clean and warm.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.2Numerous mentions of clean rooms and exceptionally clean accommodations.
Location
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
9.1Great location with easy access to local attractions.
The White Swan Inn
9.2Great location for visiting local attractions.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.2Great location noted by multiple guests.
Service
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
9.6Staff were mentioned as friendly and helpful throughout multiple reviews.
The White Swan Inn
9.1Staff in both the bar and restaurant were very welcoming and attentive.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.6Consistently praised for friendly and accommodating staff.
Sleep & Noise
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
—Best Western Forest and Vale Hotel
—The White Swan Inn
—The Old Manse Pickering
—Food & Breakfast
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
9.6Excellent food and diverse menu, with consistently positive experiences.
The White Swan Inn
8.6Food quality was excellent with great options.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.7Excellent breakfast and dining experiences highlighted by many.
Amenities & Facilities
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
8.6Amenities were generally good, though internet was noted as poor in one review.
The White Swan Inn
9.1The room had great touches such as fridge and toiletries.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.2Good amenities mentioned, including breakfast and additional comforts.
Value
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Not enough guest feedbackBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
8.0Some reviews felt the price was a bit high, but overall justified for the experience.
The White Swan Inn
8.6Overall value for the experience provided.
The Old Manse Pickering
9.1Guests felt they received great value with included breakfast and service.
Landmarks
3 Bed in Pickering oc-y035
Landmark data unavailableBest Western Forest and Vale Hotel
Cattle MarketThe White Swan Inn
Cattle MarketThe Old Manse Pickering
Potter Hill Green