Original hotel
English
Silver Sands vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Effectively tied overall
These hotels are effectively tied overall. Use the strengths, trade-offs, and key differences below to choose what matters most.
Historic Water's Edge Cottage 10
Hotels (3 selected)
Our pick
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Rockaway Beach, US
★ 4-star9.8/104 reviews
3.8 km (2.4 mi) from original
Historic Water's Edge Cottage 10
Rockaway Beach, US
★ 4-star10/101 reviews
2740.6 km (1702.9 mi) from original
Key differences
Silver Sands amenity advantages
Non-smoking rooms
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage amenity advantages
Electric vehicle charging station
Historic Water's Edge Cottage 10 amenity advantages
Air conditioning
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 2736.8 km.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage: 3.8 km (2.4 mi)
Historic Water's Edge Cottage 10: 2740.6 km (1702.9 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Silver Sands
7.7/10#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
9.8/10Historic Water's Edge Cottage 10
10/10Rooms
Silver Sands
6.1Concerns about uncomfortable and outdated beds.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackCleanliness
Silver Sands
5.7Multiple mentions of mold and unclean conditions.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackLocation
Silver Sands
9.2Repeated positive feedback about the great location and beach access.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackService
Silver Sands
8.6Staff was nice and accommodating in several mentions.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackSleep & Noise
Silver Sands
—#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
—Historic Water's Edge Cottage 10
—Food & Breakfast
Silver Sands
8.7No specific mentions, but generally positive.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackAmenities & Facilities
Silver Sands
7.7Good comments on kitchen amenities despite need for deep cleaning.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackValue
Silver Sands
8.1Considered a great value for the location, despite some issues.
#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Not enough guest feedbackHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Not enough guest feedbackLandmarks
Silver Sands
Rockaway Beach City Center & Park#StayInMyDistrict Cozy Rockaway Beach Cottage
Seaview City ParkHistoric Water's Edge Cottage 10
Boston Ferry Natural History Area