Carmelitas I Contemporary vs Similar Hotels

Rooms were generally comfortable, but some comments indicated a need for updates.

Rooms described as small and with noise issues; general dissatisfaction.

Rooms are often described as comfortable, spacious and matching photos, but there are recurring maintenance issues (old beds, broken crib, shower/ elevator problems, balcony protection concerns) that moderate the score.

Overall cleanliness was satisfactory, though some mentions indicated it could improve.

Several mentions of maintenance issues and room quality without sufficient cleanliness praise.

Multiple guests reported issues with bed linens and towels (stained/old), bathrooms not as clean as expected, and a worn toilet bowl — consistent negative mentions lowering this score.

Multiple reviews praised the excellent location, making it a strong point for the hotel.

Frequent commendation for the convenient location; many positive mentions.

Repeatedly highlighted as a major strength: excellent, central location and spectacular views mentioned across many reviews.

While some service issues were noted, overall service was rated positively by many guests.

Generally positive feedback on staff, although some inconsistency noted.

Overall very strong: many reviews praise attentive hosts and reception (helpful with adapters, luggage, friendly staff). A few isolated check-in problems and an incident with extra charges were reported, but overall service is described as exceptional by numerous guests.

Breakfast offerings were critiqued for lacking variety, impacting overall food experience.

Breakfast received some compliments, but there were issues with service.

Not mentioned in reviews; assigned the target overall rating.

Amenities were adequate, though there were suggestions for improvements in some areas.

Basic amenities mentioned; lack of gym and limited room facilities noted.

Apartments are well-equipped in appliances and utensils per some guests, but frequent complaints about missing toiletries (no shower gel/shampoo), lack of iron/remote, insufficient detergent and occasional missing toilet paper reduce this rating.

Guests felt that the value received was generally acceptable compared to the price.

Some rooms considered overpriced compared to quality; varied responses.

Several guests explicitly mention good cost-benefit and suitability for small groups; value is seen as high despite occasional extra charges or maintenance shortcomings.