Hotel Alemão Beach de Ilhabela vs Similar Hotels

Some issues with noise and comfort; air conditioning had a buzzing noise.

Some rooms were reported as dark or lacking sufficient amenities; a few guests noted issues with showers.

Guests booked the suite master and reported perfect rooms, comfortable beds, great decoration and amenities (hidro, view, etc.).

Reports of maintenance issues and noise impacted room quality sentiment.

The bathroom was reported dirty and some towels were torn.

Multiple guests reported cleanliness issues, such as moldy rooms.

Multiple reviews highlight rooms and common areas as 'muito limpo' and praise the fresh scent and overall high cleanliness.

Multiple reviews indicated issues with cleanliness, including dirty rooms and unclean bathrooms.

Great location close to many attractions, though not directly on the beach.

The location was frequently praised for being close to beaches, but noted as somewhat distant from the center.

Praised as 'pertinho da praia', with wonderful sea views and easy parking; described as excellent location near beaches.

The location received positive feedback for its proximity to beaches and pleasant surroundings.

Staff were attentive and responsive to issues raised.

Most reviews mentioned attentive and friendly staff, but there were delays in service.

Owners Edson and Fábia are repeatedly described as friendly, attentive and providing excellent reception; electronic access also simplifies check-in/check-out.

Most reviews praised the staff's friendliness and helpfulness.

Breakfast options were limited and lacked variety.

The breakfast received high praise for quality and variety, contributing positively to the overall experience.

Complimentary coffee sachets and a courtesy bottle of wine were appreciated; easy access to drinks via a 24hr fridge.

Food quality was criticized in several reviews, particularly breakfast items.

Amenities generally okay, with a nice pool but some room comfort issues.

Amenities like the pool and breakfast were generally well-received, despite some complaints about the bathrooms.

Good in-room amenities noted (linen, shampoo, soaps, bath salts, coffee sachets, courtesy wine) plus 24hr fridge for drinks and a pleasant deck/molhado area; minor note about no stove.

The hotel amenities, including pools and common areas, were positively noted.

The stay is considered good value, though some feel improvements could be made.

Guests felt the hotel provided good value for the rate, despite some complaints.

Overall very positive experience but some guests felt the cost is a bit high given no daily room service or linen change and the automatic check-in model.

Despite the issues, some guests felt the price was justified for certain experiences.