Hotel Poseidon vs Similar Hotels

Many rooms reported as spacious and recently renovated and comfortable, with family rooms and useful features (freezer, parking access), though some bathrooms are small/old and there are AC/windows maintenance issues for some guests.

Rooms were spacious but some were dated and had issues such as small showers and lack of body lotion.

Mostly reported as clean in rooms (renovated rooms, 'pulizia delle stanze', 'alles sauber'), though some guests noted unhygienic areas in parts of the hotel and poor breakfast handling.

General cleanliness was mentioned positively, but some rooms were dated and needed maintenance.

Convenient for train/port and visits to Pompeii/Vesuvio ('near station', 'location près de la gare'), but several guests mention a somewhat run-down or intimidating surrounding area ('scary to walk', 'view on dilapidated buildings').

Good location near key attractions, though some guests had difficulty finding it.

Multiple comments praise attentive and helpful staff ('personale preparato', 'hotelmanager very attentive', 'Excellent customer service'), justifying a strong positive score.

Service was consistently highlighted as welcoming and impeccable.

Most consistent negatives here: breakfast described as limited or poor quality by several guests (not varied, rotten eggs, dry croissants), though a few praised the breakfast location and variety.

Food options were abundant and well-reviewed, particularly breakfast.

Strong points: large/safe parking, private garage, bike storage and panoramic breakfast location; negatives include no pool and some intermittent fridge/AC card behavior.

General amenities received positive feedback, with a lovely pool and rooftop bar.

Mixed impressions: several guests found the price-performance 'more than okay' while others felt it was too expensive for the stated star level ('ça ne vaut pas un 4 étoiles', 'cher').

Some guests felt the hotel was expensive for what was offered, especially in the annex.