Our pick
English
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
7.9Loved that each room had its own bathroom.
Cleanliness
8.9Clean and tidy home.
Location
8.9Secure and good location.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (3 selected)
Original hotel
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
Florence Hall, JM
★ 0-star8.2/10275 reviews
Our pick
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
Florence Hall, JM
★ 4-star10/101 reviews
1.4 km (0.89 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Cleanliness
LaCondea8.9
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION8.0
Service
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION8.4
LaCondea7.9
Food & Breakfast
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION8.0
LaCondea6.9
Amenities & Facilities
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION8.5
LaCondea7.9
Value
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION8.1
LaCondea6.9
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION amenity advantages
Non-smoking roomsLuggage storage
LaCondea amenity advantages
LaundryBabysitting/child services
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated amenity advantages
Pets allowed
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.2/10LaCondea
7.9/10Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
10/10Rooms
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
7.9Rooms are comfortable but a bit dated; improvement needed.
LaCondea
7.9Loved that each room had its own bathroom.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Cleanliness
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.0Clean but dated; some issues with odors from cleaning products.
LaCondea
8.9Clean and tidy home.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Location
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.5Beautiful and quiet location near the lagoon.
LaCondea
8.9Secure and good location.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Service
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.4Very friendly and attentive staff who go out of their way to help.
LaCondea
7.9Host was helpful and friendly.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Sleep & Noise
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
—LaCondea
—Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Food & Breakfast
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.0Breakfast was sufficient given the circumstances; limited choices.
LaCondea
6.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Amenities & Facilities
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.5Pool size is good for families, WiFi is reliable; breakfast is basic but satisfactory.
LaCondea
7.9Access to a pool on top of a hill, which has an amazing view at sunset.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Value
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
8.1Fair pricing for the offered services and stay, aligns with expectations.
LaCondea
6.9Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Jhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
—Landmarks
Fisherman's Inn Hotel 294 Silver Sands road, Duncans Bay, Trelawny NEW LOCATION
Glistening WatersLaCondea
Glistening WatersJhadano 3br Pool & Gym Shuttle Gated
Glistening Waters