Our pick
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
Port Antonio, JM
★ 3-star7.5/10122 reviews
0.62 km (0.38 mi) from original
English
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
8.5Rooms were described as delightful and pleasant by guests.
Cleanliness
7.5Described as peaceful and clean in several reviews, though the pool needs cleaning and one review mentioned weak water flow in taps.
Service
9.0Multiple mentions of lovely, attentive staff and 'simply amazing' customer service; guests explicitly praised the team.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
Port Antonio, JM
★ 3-star6/100 reviews
1.6 km (0.96 mi) from original
Our pick
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
Port Antonio, JM
★ 3-star7.5/10122 reviews
0.62 km (0.38 mi) from original
Trade-offs
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
Key differences
Rooms
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa8.5
Match Resort6.8
Cleanliness
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa7.5
Match Resort6.8
Location
Match Resort8.3
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa7.5
Amenities & Facilities
Match Resort7.8
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa4.0
Value
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa7.5
Match Resort5.8
Bay View Eco Resort & Spa amenity advantages
Spa/wellness centerLaundryWheelchair accessibleBreakfast in the roomShuttle service (additional charge)
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.3 km.
Match Resort: 0.24 km (0.15 mi)
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland: 1.6 km (0.96 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
6/10Match Resort
7.6/10Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
6/10Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
7.5/10Rooms
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
6.8Some reviews indicated issues such as broken furniture, lack of amenities, and overall need for improvements.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
8.5Rooms were described as delightful and pleasant by guests.
Cleanliness
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
6.8Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness, with specific complaints about dirty rooms and areas.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
7.5Described as peaceful and clean in several reviews, though the pool needs cleaning and one review mentioned weak water flow in taps.
Location
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
8.3Location was highlighted positively, being close to beaches and town, adding to the convenience.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
7.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Service
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
8.8Guests praised the staff for being friendly and accommodating, enhancing the overall service experience.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
9.0Multiple mentions of lovely, attentive staff and 'simply amazing' customer service; guests explicitly praised the team.
Sleep & Noise
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
—Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
—Food & Breakfast
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
8.3Guests frequently complimented the food, noting good options and specific dietary accommodations.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
8.0Food largely praised (great dinners and breakfasts), though some found the breakfast menu limited or only 'ok' in variety.
Amenities & Facilities
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
7.8Amenities received mixed reviews, with some issues noted but also appreciated features like the pool.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
4.0Repeated negative comments about WiFi quality, pool cleanliness issues and poor water flow indicate weaknesses in amenities/maintenance.
Value
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
—Match Resort
5.8Many reviews pointed out that the hotel was expensive compared to the quality provided, indicating limited value.
Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
—Bay View Eco Resort & Spa
7.5Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Landmarks
Dolphin Bay Yoga Guest House
Folly Ruins (1905)Match Resort
Folly Ruins (1905)Serenity 2-bed Apartment in Port Antonio, Portland
Rotary ParkBay View Eco Resort & Spa
Folly Ruins (1905)