
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence





San Andrés, CO
1.7 km (1.0 mi) from original
What you may gain by choosing another hotel.
The compared hotels differ by 0.99 km.
Villa Sunny Days: 1.1 km (0.65 mi)
POSADA MISS ANIBEL: 2.0 km (1.3 mi)
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10/10Villa Sunny Days
8.9/10POSADA MISS ANIBEL
8.9/10Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.6/10Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0Guest expressed satisfaction with the home and its beauty.
Villa Sunny Days
8.8Rooms were generally spacious and comfortable, with some comments on bedding issues.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
9.2Rooms were comfortable and well-equipped with amenities.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.2Rooms are described as small and may lack features like suitable charging ports, impacting overall satisfaction.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0Guest mentioned cleanliness positively in their review.
Villa Sunny Days
8.5Most reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, though some noted issues with water problems.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
8.2Some mentions of cleanliness, but noted that it could improve.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.2Some reviews mentioned cleanliness positively, but there are consistency issues due to noise disturbances and minor complaints.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0Guest mentioned that it is uphill in town, requiring a scooter to get to the beach.
Villa Sunny Days
9.1Location was highlighted as ideal for beach access, though some noted it was away from the center.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
8.2Location is slightly far from the center, but still a good value for the service provided.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.7The location is praised for being convenient and peaceful, but it's also noted to be a bit far from some attractions.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0Guest praised the great attitude of the host and their helpfulness.
Villa Sunny Days
9.3The staff received consistent praise for being friendly, helpful, and accommodating.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
9.7Guests highlighted the exceptional service provided by Junior and Arnulfo.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
9.2The service received high praise across multiple reviews, indicating a consistently positive sentiment.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
—Villa Sunny Days
—POSADA MISS ANIBEL
—Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
—Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0No specific mention, assumed standard quality for this hotel tier.
Villa Sunny Days
8.8The on-site restaurant was noted as solid, although some guests had mixed feelings.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
8.7Food options were available but not specifically rated in reviews.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.2Food options received mixed reviews, indicating room for improvement.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0Guests appreciated the availability of swimming goggles and water shoes.
Villa Sunny Days
8.4While there were useful amenities, some guests wished for more dining options nearby.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
8.9Amenities were adequate, including a well-equipped kitchen and other facilities.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.7Positive mentions of amenities like the kayak service and cleanliness, though some areas could improve.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
10.0Guests felt that the offerings justified the cost.
Villa Sunny Days
8.9Guests felt they received good value for the price, considering the location and service.
POSADA MISS ANIBEL
9.2Guests felt they received good value given the quality of service and comfort.
Mangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
8.7The pricing is deemed acceptable in relation to the experience provided, though some items could be better.
Posada Nativa Atardecer Isleño
Jardin Botanico de San AndresVilla Sunny Days
ShipwreckPOSADA MISS ANIBEL
Mirador La LomaMangrove Bay Hotel San Andrés Islas
La Mansion