Our pick
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
Westport, CA
★ 3-star10/1046 reviews
798.1 km (495.9 mi) from original
English
Brier Island Lodge vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
10.0Beautiful property inside and out.
Cleanliness
10.0Clean rooms based on positive guest mentions.
Location
10.0Perfect location at the river and close to restaurants.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (3 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
Westport, CA
★ 3-star10/1046 reviews
798.1 km (495.9 mi) from original
The Victorian Luxury Suites
Westport, CA
★ 0-star9.5/10245 reviews
798.2 km (496.0 mi) from original
Key differences
Rooms
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge7.5
Cleanliness
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge8.0
Location
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge9.0
Service
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge8.5
Food & Breakfast
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge8.5
Amenities & Facilities
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge7.5
Value
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast10.0
Brier Island Lodge7.0
Brier Island Lodge amenity advantages
RestaurantBeach toys
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast amenity advantages
Free breakfastElectric car charging stationWheelchair accessibleAccessible shuttle
The Victorian Luxury Suites amenity advantages
WiFi availableAir conditioningLuggage storagePets allowedSkiing
Detailed comparison
Guest score
Brier Island Lodge
8/10Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10/10The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.5/10Rooms
Brier Island Lodge
7.5Rooms are basic and some have noise issues; however, they are clean.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Beautiful property inside and out.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.3A beautiful old Victorian home converted to B&B; the room was lovely and comfortable.
Cleanliness
Brier Island Lodge
8.0Reviews mention rooms being very clean and comfortable.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Clean rooms based on positive guest mentions.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.3The room was spacious & very comfortably furnished - & so clean!
Location
Brier Island Lodge
9.0Wonderful location with scenic views and convenient to whale watching.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Perfect location at the river and close to restaurants.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.8Excellent location with plenty of shops and beautiful walks.
Service
Brier Island Lodge
8.5Staff are frequently described as friendly and helpful.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Wonderful hosts who provide excellent service.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.8The host, Stephanie, was lovely, very friendly and amenable.
Sleep & Noise
Brier Island Lodge
—Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
—The Victorian Luxury Suites
—Food & Breakfast
Brier Island Lodge
8.5Food is frequently praised, especially the breakfast and dinner.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Amazing breakfasts that guests rave about.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.3Breakfast delicious and delivered to the room; warm blueberry muffins were delightful.
Amenities & Facilities
Brier Island Lodge
7.5Basic amenities mentioned, with lack of air conditioning noted.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Open spaces for guests to use are available.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.3The room comes with a gorgeous tub and shower; kitchenette with coffee machine and fridge.
Value
Brier Island Lodge
7.0Some reviewers felt the experience did not match the price paid.
Upper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
10.0Great experience for the price.
The Victorian Luxury Suites
9.3Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Landmarks
Brier Island Lodge
Welcome Aboard Whale Watching ToursUpper Rideau Bed & Breakfast
Spy RockThe Victorian Luxury Suites
Lockwood Memorial Park