Our pick
English
日月潭 3JD home 一館 vs Similar Hotels
Compare similar hotels across guest insights, rooms, location, amenities, value, nearby attractions and suitability to understand the trade-offs before you choose.
What matters most to you?
Lodgegrid Decision Intelligence
Best overall fit
✓Why it stands out
Rooms
9.8Hand-built property full of character and individuality; truly unique, bucket-list style accommodation.
Cleanliness
9.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
Location
9.8Beautiful, lush grounds adjacent to a tea leaf farm; very scenic and unique setting.
Close alternatives
No close alternative was identified for this preference.
Hotels (4 selected)
Original hotel
Our pick
Key differences
Rooms
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel7.8
Cleanliness
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel7.9
Location
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel8.9
Service
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel8.9
Food & Breakfast
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel7.9
Amenities & Facilities
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel6.9
Value
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格9.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel7.8
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel amenity advantages
Lift / Elevator
Secret Homestay amenity advantages
Swimming poolPets allowedElectric vehicle charging station
Distance from original
The compared hotels differ by 1.3 km.
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel: 0.20 km (0.13 mi)
Secret Homestay: 1.5 km (0.95 mi)
Detailed comparison
Guest score
日月潭 3JD home 一館
8.8/10日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8/10日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
8/10Secret Homestay
8.9/10Rooms
日月潭 3JD home 一館
8.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Hand-built property full of character and individuality; truly unique, bucket-list style accommodation.
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
7.8The room was comfortable but the air conditioning was an issue.
Secret Homestay
8.6Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Cleanliness
日月潭 3JD home 一館
8.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
7.9Overall cleanliness was good but the shower pressure was noted as low.
Secret Homestay
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Location
日月潭 3JD home 一館
9.1環境舒適、便利
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Beautiful, lush grounds adjacent to a tea leaf farm; very scenic and unique setting.
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
8.9The location is convenient with nearby food options.
Secret Homestay
9.7Distance to Sun Moon Lake is close.
Service
日月潭 3JD home 一館
9.1老闆親切
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Hosts were helpful, kind and generous—provided lifts into town and attentive personalized service.
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
8.9The staff, particularly Mary Grace, was welcoming and helpful.
Secret Homestay
9.2Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Sleep & Noise
日月潭 3JD home 一館
—日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
—日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
—Secret Homestay
—Food & Breakfast
日月潭 3JD home 一館
9.1迎賓禮的點心很好吃，讚嘆老闆們的手藝
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Homemade breakfasts described as delicious, fresh and varied each day, with great coffee.
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
7.9Proximity to food stalls adds value.
Secret Homestay
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Amenities & Facilities
日月潭 3JD home 一館
8.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Stunning grounds and abundant plant life (large and small ferns) that enhance the property experience.
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
6.9Missing amenities such as a bidet were suggested for improvement.
Secret Homestay
8.7Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Value
日月潭 3JD home 一館
8.6Standard quality for this hotel tier
日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
9.8Standard quality for this hotel tier
日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
7.8The stay was reasonably priced for the level of service provided.
Secret Homestay
8.6Standard quality for this hotel tier.
Landmarks
日月潭 3JD home 一館
魚池鄉水源保護區界 04日月潭秘密花園設計Villa-獨特手作建造風格
魚池鄉水源保護區界 03日月潭魚池鄉秀水民宿Xiu Shui Hotel
魚池鄉水源保護區界 04Secret Homestay
魚池鄉水源保護區界 04